Scottish Sunday

Discover Your Perfect Stay

Holyrood Bill Must Breathe Life Into the Euthanasia Debate

Fifth Column: Jeremy Purvis wants us to challenge one of modern society’s most contentious taboos: legally assisted suicide

For some, the sanctity of life is absolute. Only God can take life, in all circumstances and with no exceptions. I respect this view, but I do not hold to it. Important as the sanctity of life is, it has to take second place to personal autonomy – the right of self-determination – which is at the heart of Scots law and is now enshrined in the European Convention of Human Rights.

A Deficient Law

We know, through countless surveys of doctors over the past 10 years that assisted dying takes place, but unlike Oregon in the US and the Netherlands, reporting remains at zero. There are no safeguards for patients and no legal protection for doctors.

I have had a living will – or advance directive – for 15 years. This gives me a degree of control over my treatment (or withdrawal of such) in case I can no longer make a contemporaneous request. According to BMA guidelines, to disregard a living will is the same as assault. The limit to advance directives, of course, is that they do not go further than the withdrawal of treatment.

In my view, the law as it stands is deficient in respect of those patients with a terminal illness (with a prognosis of death within months) as some patients are being denied the right to remain in control of their lives until their death, and the right, as they see it, to die with dignity.

A Global Perspective

In 1994, a public referendum in Oregon approved Measure 16, the Death with Dignity Act, and in 1997, after legal challenges, physician-assisted suicide became a legal medical option for the terminally ill in the state. The original vote was far from decisive: 51% in favor, 49% opposed. However, after a further vote and attempts to have the law revoked, voters chose to retain the act by 60% to 40%. The Dutch and Belgian parliaments have decriminalized euthanasia.

Motor neurone disease sufferer Diane Pretty endured years of legal struggle to be able to choose when to die; she was refused this right and died in due course as a result of her illness. This case provoked much debate, but we shouldn’t wait until the next high-profile case to start that debate again. And we must also consider whether a change in the law may bring with it more social harm than good.

The Role of Medical Professionals

All physicians, alongside nurses, caregivers, volunteers, the emergency services, and others, deal in life and death, which often places them at the heart of medical and moral debates. They deal with the families of patients when these families are going through difficult periods in their lives. They’re also, with the exception of a tiny minority of unprofessional cases, deeply caring and moral people. Doctor-assisted suicide is among the most contentious issues that physicians around the world face. It should also be an issue that the Scottish parliament debates.

Dr. Peter Goodwin, a family physician for more than 50 years in Oregon, wrote: “Solid academic research indicates legal-assisted dying has been a powerful catalyst for a multitude of improvements in end-of-life care. These innovations have not been confined to the Oregon borders but, rather, have spread across the country. Palliative care and pain management are now at the forefront of medical consciousness.”

Hotels in Scotland: Finding Comfort Away from Home

Unwind and Relax in Scottish Hospitality

Scotland offers a wide range of hotels that cater to every traveler's needs. Whether you're looking for a luxury getaway or a budget-friendly accommodation, you'll find a comfortable home away from home in Scotland's hotels.

Explore the Beauty of Scotland

From the historical charm of Edinburgh to the breathtaking landscapes of the Highlands, Scotland has plenty to offer for tourists. Stay in a centrally located hotel in Edinburgh and immerse yourself in the city's rich history and vibrant culture. Alternatively, escape to the tranquil countryside and choose a hotel nestled amidst the stunning Scottish Highlands.

Diverse Accommodation Options

Scotland's hotel industry is known for its variety. Whether you prefer a boutique hotel with personalized service or a large chain hotel with modern amenities, there's something for everyone. Many hotels also offer unique experiences such as spa facilities, golf courses, and traditional Scottish cuisine.

Booking Made Easy

Planning your stay in Scotland is effortless with the availability of online booking platforms. Compare prices, read guest reviews, and choose the perfect hotel that fits your preferences and budget. From cozy bed and breakfasts to luxury five-star hotels, the options are endless.

When visiting Scotland, rest assured that the hospitality of its hotels will ensure a memorable and comfortable stay. Enjoy the warm welcome and explore the beauty of this stunning country.

Manchester

Edinburgh

Brighton

Liverpool

Nottingham

Torquay

Bath

Cardiff

Southampton

Cambridge (Cambridgeshire)

Windsor

Weston-super-Mare

Harrogate

Exeter

Plymouth

Coventry

Swansea

Watford (Hertfordshire)

Dublin

Ipswich