Home
August 30, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
Business is failing to keep up with web revolution
Survey shows Scottish companies are not embracing interactive applications

SCOTLAND'S BUSINESSES are failing to keep pace with the web 2.0 phenomenon. Despite a welter of global excitement generated by the new generation of interactive web applications such as social networking and user-generated content, the failure of small and medium-sized companies to embrace such advances has awoken concern among the sector's major players.

Calling upon Scotland's commercial sector to bridge a fast-widening productivity gap, Cisco's top technologist has warned that unless SMEs keep up with the pace of change, they risk placing themselves at a serious disadvantage.

"There is a revolution going on that Scottish businesses, particularly SMEs, are missing out on. It is something that could be used to enhance the productivity and profitability of every company, but across every sector companies seem to have been reluctant to take advantage of the situation," said Richard Moir, Cisco Scotland's chief technology officer.

"There is a vast array of web 2.0 applications out there that anyone with limited technical expertise could use to improve any number of business processes from marketing to research to company administration. Yet while an increasing number of people spend their leisure time using the same technologies at home, we are not carrying that knowledge over into the workplace."

The recent news that social-networking site Bebo has now overtaken Google as the UK's most visited web destination underlines how the way people use the internet is rapidly evolving. Lightweight online applications that allow users to communicate and collaborate on the fly have proliferated, and a raft of companies using these tools to streamline and expand their operations have emerged over the past two years.

A recent Cisco survey found that 32% of Scottish organisations believe they are being held back by an inability to respond to change, considerably more than the 20% figure reported in England and Wales. Underlining a worrying trend, the study found that while only 5% of firms south of the Border were technically incapable of supporting advances like teleworking, in Scotland that figure rose to 11%.

Despite the global excitement generated by web 2.0, the research reveals that Caledonia isn't keeping pace. Some 57% of the decision makers surveyed said that economic life had become less personal as a result of technology, with 75% listing personal recommendations as the top reason to do business with a company, yet only 27% are now using the internet to network with potential partners and customers.

Smaller businesses are missing a trick. The internet is no stranger to hype and industry commentators understand why many might view the current focus on such tools with some scepticism, but most agree that the second generation of web applications holds tremendous potential.

"There has been a lot of hype about social networking, but the fact is that if you get it right it works. Using blogs, podcasts and sites like Facebook can improve your business's profile and deliver revenue, but it's not just about sales and marketing. It's another example of the way the web changes our ability to deliver goods and services," said Richard Mahony, senior analyst at Ovum.

Cisco believes that part of the reluctance to embrace the next generation is spawned by the nature of the knowledge involved. The company points out that, as is often the case in the technology sector, the vast majority of web 2.0 skills and applications have been developed ad-hoc, with self-teaching users acquiring the necessary skills through practice and perseverance. While these abilities might be powering a consumer phenomenon, they lack the certified credibility most businesses seek.

In an attempt to combat the problem, Cisco has joined a host of IT companies such as Sun Microsystems in calling upon Scotland's business community to address its skills gap using existing available services such as Scottish Enterprise's e-Skills Academy. Supported by the universities of Strathclyde and Paisley, the initiative offers a range of low-cost training courses and seminars designed to equip companies with the expertise they need to progress.

Responding to the suggestion that many small businesses are too busy with their core operations to expand time or money on exploring a entirely new field, a spokesman for Scottish Enterprise recognised the difficulties facing many firms when considering the use of new technology. He claimed that the organisation had learned from previous failures and formulated an approach designed to minimise the impact of re-skilling.

"In the past, a valid criticism of such courses has been that they are too focused on the core technology. In light of this we have designed a series of sessions which focus on how these relate to your individual business, irrespective of whether you are a plumber or a financial adviser," said Russell Stevenson, manager for innovation and ICT at Scottish Enterprise.

"The focus now has to be on practicality. We understand the pressures SMEs are under, but can help them come to terms with the new ways of doing business in a manner that complements their existing operation."

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: Sanjiv Swarup, India on 3:59am Sun 7 Oct 07
I have been using 2.0 applications for two years now for all my SMB clients. Google Docs, Zoho, and now eDeskOnline. I understand all OFFICE functionalities are moving to the mobile phone: and web 2.0 enables moves towards it.
Posted by: Cisco Kid, Sun City on 9:11am Sun 7 Oct 07
a welter of global excitement generated by the new generation of interactive web applications such as social networking and user-generated content, the failure of small and medium-sized companies to embrace such advances has awoken concern among the sector's major players


A couple of points
The concern amongst the major players could also be described as big suppliers like Cisco upset as their potential customers are not falling for hyped sales patter. Ironically this is partly because social networking and user generated content are allowing lots of frustrated and disappointed actual customers to say how little the new technology has benefited them. Suddenly the big marketing budgets of the big industry players no longer win every argument and they are the ones who don’t know what to do as a response
The problem with the new democratic web technologies is that all voices are equal. Cisco has only one voice alongside the voice of its several million customers. Of course it can ask/encourage/cajole its employees to blog and contribute content under their own names (and there are examples of companies doing just that – holiday resort reviews being a prime instance) But the risk is the very anonymity that the parent company is relying upon allows the employees to snipe from the sidelines and – dare I say - it tell the truth. (in case anyone is confused, it may be worth mentioning that my name is not really Cisco Kid)
There may be no technological barrier to promoting your product/service through blogs and social sites but the risks in doing this to an increasingly and sceptical audience are not to be underestimated. Also significant are the huge time costs that running multiple web identities and keeping numerous posts going incur.
What is missing from the article, and indeed form the alarmed comments from Cisco and Sun is any examples of a small, medium sized, or even big company who have got this right. From time to time there have been soar away successes driven by viral marketing but often these are accidents outside the supplier’s control. Planned campaigns are more likely to crash and burn, being help up to ridicule by a street wise audience.
The success of Bebo and Facebook is significant and undeniable but let’s see some examples of how any SMEs, anywhere in the world have harnessed this for effective business promotion before we roll over and absorb the latest IT industry press releases encouraging us to spend more on their products
Posted by: 2.0 Pro, Glasgow on 7:01pm Sun 7 Oct 07
What's missing from the article is that it's not a fear of technology which holds Scottish businesses back, it's insecurity and a fear of loss of control. Ours is still very much a "sit where we can see you" working culture. And having seen managers who, to this day, keep vital company records handwritten in WH Smith A4 notebooks, it's no wonder they're terrified to allow employees to work from home on their own initiative.

There's more on this issue here:
http://www.e-consult
ancy.com/news-blog/3
61331/the-12-reasons
-why-uk-businesses-d
on-t-blog.html
Posted by: e-arlybird, Argyll on 9:38am Mon 8 Oct 07
A good article but doesn't go far enough.
There is a revolution going on that Scottish businesses, particularly SMEs, are missing out on

It's called Web 1.0 - many Scottish SMEs have failed even to take the first step. The standard of SME websites is very poor, the UK in general is dire, looking and feeling more 90's than nought's.
However, some small companies have embraced web 2.0 and are making it easier for customers to deal with them. In larger companies the erosion of IT 'skills' afforded by the simple, cheap web 2.0 apps creates a paranoia that sees many websites being blocked. Some companies still block Google, RSS feeds, BBC - someone might listen to the radio!!!!!!!!!!!!!
New entrants to the workforce have grown up with Web, IM, Bebo etc when they enter the corporate world it must be like stepping back in time :o)
Add your comment
Name:
Email: *
Location:
**
Security Image. Registered site users are not required to enter Security Image Information.
 
 e.g. 123-123
Comment:
Please note: All HTML tags will be ignored.
Format Text:

 
By posting a comment, I confirm that I have read and agree to the terms of use. Comments are not moderated but we will react if anything that breaks the rules comes to our attention and we may delete inappropriate postings. Please treat other people with respect. You must not post anything that is abusive, indecent, unlawful or defamatory. Remember, you are personally liable for what you post on this site. If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us here.
* Your email address will not be displayed
** To avoid register now or login