Home
July 04, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
Catholic bishops uneasy at demand for new mosques
Move to recreate ancient place of worship causes tension in city of Córdoba
By Elizabeth Nash in Madrid

SPAIN'S CATHOLIC bishops are mobilising against Muslim plans to recreate the Andalusian city of Crdoba as a huge pilgrimage site for Muslims throughout Europe.

Crdoba's Muslim community wants to build a half-size replica of the eighth-century mosque in the city that was once heart of the ancient Islamic kingdom of al-Andalus. Crdoba's Muslim Association is seeking funds for the project from the governments of the United Arab Emirates and Kuwait, and Muslim organisations in Morocco and Egypt. The complex would include schools, conference centres, a hotel, library, sports fields, a swimming pool and shops, said the association's president, Abu-Muhammad Abdullah-Imram.

Another giant Saudi-funded mosque is planned near the ancient fortress palace of Medina Azahara, a heritage site just outside Crdoba. Similar mosques are planned for Seville and Granada.

But bishops are alarmed at the prospect of huge, eye-catching mosques, fearing the Catholic Church's waning influence may be further eclipsed by resurgent Islam financed from abroad. One million Muslims, immigrants and converts, are estimated to live in Spain, with the largest community - around 250,000 - in Andalusia. Many are drawn by the area's Islamic heritage and a romantic nostalgia for the lost paradise of the kingdom of al-Andalus that ruled Spain for more than 500 years.

Spanish Muslims recently relaunched a long-standing campaign for the right to pray in Crdoba's great mosque, a jewel of Islamic culture and one of Spain's most treasured heritage sites. Mansur Escudero, president of Spain's Islamic Council, unrolled his prayer mat last month at the mosque's west door and kneeled to pray, in defiance of a Catholic veto.

The mosque contains a glittering mihrab, or prayer niche, which is regarded as an architectural wonder of the world. It also houses a cathedral, built to consolidate Catholic rule after Muslims were expelled from Spain in 1492. Muslims are forbidden to pray in any part of the building.

"Joint acts of prayer between Christians and Muslims would do more for ecumenicalism and inter-religious dialogue than theological debates among religious leaders," said Escudero. But the archbishop of Crdoba, Juan Jose Asenjo, insisted that joint use of the mosque was "not viable, would not contribute to peaceful co-existence and would only generate confusion among the faithful".

The polemic was re-ignited when the pope, Benedict XVI, visited Turkey in November and prayed in Istanbul's Blue Mosque. "That was a tremendously positive sign to Muslims. It showed that mosques are open to Christian worshippers," said Escudero. "Why can't Muslims pray in Crdoba's mosque?"

Escudero wrote to the pope, and put the question to the head of Spain's Episcopal Conference, bishop Ricardo Blazquez of Bilbao. Blazquez, caught on the hop, replied that while collective worship was prohibited, he supposed private or individual prayer was acceptable.

Escudero then called upon Muslims to go to Crdoba's mosque to pray "in a respectful, private and individual capacity". But the bishops declared that "Muslims cannot in any way pray in Crdoba cathedral". There would, they stated, be "no negotiation whatsoever over the use of the cathedral under the pretext of a false inter-religious dialogue".

Following Escudero's public pray-in on December 27, archbishop Asenjo made his counter-move, calling on Crdoba's Protestant, Orthodox and Evangelical communities to join a week of prayer starting this Thursday. It was a rare ecumenical gesture; Spain's Catholics rarely show interest in other Christian groups.

Muslims in Spain have long been respectful to the country's ecclesiastical and civil authorities, but as numbers have swelled they have turned to more radical leaders. An alliance of Spanish converts, pro-Moroccan and pro-Saudi leaders took control of one of Spain's two main Islamic federations last year. Rising new leaders include fundamentalist imams from Saudi-funded mosques in Madrid and Fuengirola. They want Catholics to recognise Crdoba's mosque as "a patrimony of two, or three, cultures" - there was once a synagogue on the site.

The moderate Escudero does not favour the construction of ostentatious mosques with foreign money. "I prefer modest, decent buildings backed by Spanish local authorities," he said, but added: "Muslims have the right to build mosques big and small where they like."

Improvised mosques have popped up in homes and garages all over Spain, especially in Andalusia, to meet demand. But churches resist the building of flashy mosques that dominate the skyline. Many parishioners complain they are funded by undemocratic countries to promote Islamic radicalism.

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: knighthospitaller on 6:16am Sun 14 Jan 07
"Why can't Muslims pray in Cordoba's mosque?", asks Escuardo. I answer with a series of questions that the entire Christian world, including the post-Christian west should be asking: Why don't the Turkish authorities return Hagia Sophia to the Ecumenical Patriarchate or at least allow the Greek Orthodox community to build new churches or repair some of their old ones? Why don't they return Halke Seminary to the Orthdox Church? Why is it a crime to even possess a Bible or Christian literature in Saudi Arabia or to utter a Christian prayer in the privacy of one's own home if one is a Christian living and working there? Why are Christians in Palestine forced to flee to the new world to escape the increasing harrassment of militant Moslems there? Why do Saudi imams routinely denounce Christians and Jews as "pigs" and "apes"? Why did Abdul Rahman have to flee in fear for his life from Afghanistan to Italy when he converted to Christianity?

Need I go on? Let the Muslim world correct these appaling injustices and then we can talk about the Cordoba Mosque. In the meantime, Muslims in the West are treated with admirable toleration and benevolence, and they should cease their incessant demands!
Posted by: LWS on 3:53pm Sun 14 Jan 07
The only correct action is to discourage the practiceT of superstition. A moratorium on construction of any more temples, mosques and churches is essential. The God Delusion should be mandatory reading at school and no children should be abused emotionally or physically (circumcsion) by adults filling their heads with nonsense. Religion is the greatest threat to human intellectual progress.
http://richarddawkins.net/home
Posted by: Al7awra2, Malaysia on 7:30pm Wed 17 Oct 07
dear knighthospitaller your 1st point might be right but there are a few other points that you said that are really wrong 1st you blamed muslims for the fleeing of christains in palastine it wasnt the muslims who caused them to flee but it was the jews who did killing the men and burning there hourses raping there woman using no form of humanity did you hear bout how severly palestinians were toutured in the jewish jails?? i mean after all this you are questioning us for calling them pigs and apes??? as for y we calling them like was because of a punishment that god layed on them long ago during the prophets time i just cant remember which one of the prophets was it anyway as for wat you said bout ppl in the muslim country practicing other religons than everyone knows that cristians are even free to celebrate their christmas int hose countries ther ewas once this gulf country i think it was kuwait it made full chrismas preperations for christmas they had a chrismas tree they eveb included things that are against to our religion like have the statue of jesus in the crib and according to our religion this is HARAM..... so i guess now that when you tok next time you can think twice mayb even read a book before you read or just dont tok as mohammed PBUH said he better say sumthing right or else he be quiet !!!!!
Add your comment
Name:
Email: *
Location:
**
Security Image. Registered site users are not required to enter Security Image Information.
 
 e.g. 123-123
Comment:
Please note: All HTML tags will be ignored.
Format Text:

 
By posting a comment, I confirm that I have read and agree to the terms of use. Comments are not moderated but we will react if anything that breaks the rules comes to our attention and we may delete inappropriate postings. Please treat other people with respect. You must not post anything that is abusive, indecent, unlawful or defamatory. Remember, you are personally liable for what you post on this site. If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us here.
* Your email address will not be displayed
** To avoid register now or login