Home
October 12, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
Delhi’s poorest left behind in drive to make city ready for 2010 games
City chiefs demolish Delhi’s slums, fuelling India’s homeless crisis
From Raymond Thibodeaux in New Delhi

FOR MANOJ Kumar and hundreds of other unemployed labourers camped out under shredded tarps beside a chaotic intersection of this bustling capital, the forthcoming Commonwealth Games was a harbinger of new prosperity: more jobs, better roads and decent housing for their families.

But instead, as New Delhi tries to spruce up and transform itself into a modern city in time for the 2010 games, Kumar finds himself fending off city authorities from bulldozing the shelters where his family and 40 others have lived in tarpaulin and burlap tents for 25 years. For Kumar, it's a case of déjà vu.

"Most of these families were moved here from another part of Delhi to make way for 1982 Asian Games," said Kumar, 35, an ironworker and toolmaker. "Now, the city is moving us again to make way for the Commonwealth Games."

The father of six is not alone. In the months leading up to the games, more than 5000 families have been forced from their homes as the city authorities demolished hundreds of slums and encampments around New Delhi, a crowded, traffic-choked city of 14 million people.

New Delhi already has 150,000 homeless residents - the vast majority of them women and children - a staggering figure that critics say is largely ignored by city leaders.

India's economic boom is fuelling the surge in urban growth as millions of subsistence farmers flee the relentless poverty of the countryside for the hope of better jobs in the cities. Like many of India's large hubs, Delhi has been undergoing massive transformation, with many urban renewal projects spurred by the forthcoming Commonwealth Games, which have been held every four years in Britain and its former colonies since 1930. India hopes to use the games as a springboard for its planned 2020 Olympic bid.

But Delhi's handling of its homeless population has brought into sharp focus a larger problem facing India, an emerging superpower where the needs of the country's 70 million homeless, mostly women and children, are often brushed aside as the gap widens between the haves and the have-nots.

India is spending more than $400 million (£200m) to polish Delhi's image as a first-rate capital, a difficult task for a city that seems to exist between the first and third worlds.

Amid its ritzy, tree-lined neighbourhoods and shining five-star hotels is the reeking squalor of slums, crumbling roads, open sewage, water shortages and almost daily power outages.

Before the games begin, Delhi's chief minister, Sheila Dikshit, has vowed to rid the city of slums, which she says have no place in a modern city. In public statements, she has said that demolishing slums is a humane act, mainly because it forces people to seek alternatives to the crowded squalor of the settlements, which are often illegal and have no running water or electricity.

"The city doesn't want the world to see this," said Anouradha Bakshi, pointing to a grungy row of shanties where dozens of dishevelled street urchins wander among stray dogs and chickens sifting through the garbage along the busy road in south Delhi.

"Delhi wants to present itself as a first-world city, but this shows its failure to provide the most basic services for the poor. We can't just hide our poor or wish them away," said Bakshi, founder of Project Why, a charity that provides free primary education for children from the city's many slums.

More than 300 residents of this settlement, known as Maharana Pratap Camp, have petitioned the Delhi high court to stop the destruction of their shelters by city planners seeking to extend Delhi's subway system - yet another of Delhi's urban renewal projects to be completed before the games.

On Delhi's busy roadways, hordes of barefoot street children peddling paper napkins and necklaces of marigolds have become as much a fixture as cows, which many Hindus - India's predominant religion - consider sacred. Often, the children's parents force them into the traffic to beg, counting on their children's vulnerability to draw out sympathy and spare change from commuters.

Advocates for the city's homeless have tendered numerous plans to provide housing for thousands of people left homeless by slum demolitions.

One plan involves moving about 3000 homeless women and children from the streets of Delhi into an abandoned 14-acre ashram in Rishikesh - about five hours by train north of Delhi - where The Beatles studied meditation with the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi in 1968.

Some city planners have pitched an idea to relocate thousands of the city's beggars, mostly children and handicapped people, into camps on the city's fringes before and during the Commonwealth Games, a plan that critics say hides, rather than solves, the problem.

"We want to see a range of schemes that help children, but this doesn't sound like something we would support. It's not good to uproot children from their normal environment. It's better to integrate them locally," said Renuka Chaudhary, director of India's Ministry of Women and Children.

Ironically, the city's facelift leading up to the games is contributing to its homeless problem as thousands of unskilled labourers and their families migrate to Delhi for construction jobs, most of which pay minimum wage of roughly $4 per day or less. The influx of unskilled workers has led to a sudden mushrooming of tent cities around many of the construction sites.

Still, many in Delhi are optimistic that the Commonwealth Games will be a windfall for both the rich and the poor. The event is expected to bring in more than $17 billion as an estimated one million spectators flock to Delhi's tourist hotels, restaurants and shopping malls during the 11 days of the games.

"Whether they make this city into another Singapore or Hong Kong doesn't matter to us," said Kumar as he eyed the tangle of traffic near his stand of handmade tools. "We're happy the games are here, but we're the ones paying the price to have them."

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: Wullie on 11:43pm Sat 15 Dec 07
Widespread corruption and a caste system that would make our Victorian society look like a model of social care and concern.

That together with a total lack of compassion for your fellow human being is why India has the appalling slums that it has.

Not my concern, as they pass some poor street person.

A world superpower in exploitation, one has to question how the country will remain stable as the hundreds of millions of poor come to realize their plight in the modern era of communication.

Yes, we need to guard and protect our freedoms and rights here. These were hard fought and won here as they will be in developing countries like India.
Posted by: James, Dundee on 10:49am Sun 16 Dec 07
What they need is a few Labour Councillors. We've got a few to spare.
Posted by: I'm no really here on 1:01pm Sun 16 Dec 07
Same thing happens in every third-world country that is given these events. The politicians strut about, and there is NO WAY they are going to be made to look cheap on the world stage. Their events must be bigger, better and more expensive than the last - regardless of how many of their people die of hunger and disease in the process. The same process is happening in SA for the 2010 World Cup. Hospital buildings put on hold, funding cut. In 2010 all eyes will be focused on the opening event, and not the dead and dying just outside the stadium.
Posted by: campbell waterman on 1:08pm Sun 16 Dec 07
Having just returned from Delhi I can vouch for this article. However the problem goes much further than just the Games.India as a democratic society will burst apart if its dramatic economic progress does not filter down through its entire society and the poor,not only become poorer,but are sunk further into the mires of the increased pollution this "progress" is bringing.
Posted by: BM, Scotland on 6:46pm Sun 16 Dec 07
For Delhi read Glasgow and for 2010 read 2014.
Posted by: RJKT on 12:16pm Mon 17 Dec 07
Wullie:"That together with a total lack of compassion for your fellow human being is why India has the appalling slums that it has."

Q.E.D.

How about the homeless ( mostly white males )shivering through chilly winter nights on London's Strand. And barely able to whisper 'change please' to well heeled passers-by the next morning.
Add your comment
Name:
Email: *
Location:
**
Security Image. Registered site users are not required to enter Security Image Information.
 
 e.g. 123-123
Comment:
Please note: All HTML tags will be ignored.
Format Text:

 
By posting a comment, I confirm that I have read and agree to the terms of use. Comments are not moderated but we will react if anything that breaks the rules comes to our attention and we may delete inappropriate postings. Please treat other people with respect. You must not post anything that is abusive, indecent, unlawful or defamatory. Remember, you are personally liable for what you post on this site. If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us here.
* Your email address will not be displayed
** To avoid register now or login