Home
September 07, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
Call for men to help tackle prostitution
Elaine C Smith says male attitudes are part of the problem

THE ACTRESS and comedian Elaine C Smith has called for a change in male attitudes towards prostitution as women are increasingly trafficked into Scotland for sex.

Smith, a trustee of the anti-domestic violence charity Zero Tolerance, believes schemes should be set up to educate men against sexual exploitation.

The star also attacked the GMB union, accusing it of "legitimising" the lap-dancing industry after it set up a branch for table dancers to lobby clubs for better pay and conditions.

Smith's comments came at the launch last week of A Rose, By Any Other Name, a collection of poetry and short stories by women who had been driven into homelessness and prostitution.

More than 600 copies of the book, the first of its kind in Scotland, have been published through Glasgow's Routes Into Learning adult literacy project. Many of the women could barely write before attending the classes, yet have penned fascinating and moving tales of their harrowing experiences for the free book which will be distributed around the country.

Smith said: "The level of domestic violence, domestic abuse, sexual abuse, prostitution and sex trafficking going on within our country is still at levels that are completely unacceptable.

"I am still very concerned that women are perpetuated as the victim and very rarely, as far as I am concerned, is the behaviour of men within that situation actually challenged."

She also attacked union activity in the sex industry, adding: "We can talk about prostitution and sex trafficking and we now unfortunately have women coming out and saying, Oh no, I'm a lap-dancer through choice.' We actually have some of the trade unions now trying to organise women in lap-dancing, which I find a bit crazy.

"I am not saying the union is not supportive of Zero Tolerance or Women's Aid, but they are in a way legitimising lap-dancing and prostitution."

Smith won backing from the leading American feminist Janice Raymond, an executive director of the Coalition Against Trafficking in Women, which works closely with the United Nations to tackle the problem.

She said the GMB should follow the example of Norway's trade unions, which stopped supporting lap-dancers because of their profession's links with sexual exploitation.

Raymond, who collected the Zero Tolerance woman of the year award at a ceremony in Glasgow last night, wants young men targeted in schools in an attempt to shape male attitudes towards prostitution, pornography and sexual exploitation from an early age.

She said: "Many young men are more aware of the kinds of issues, including prostitution, exploitation and poverty, and we really need them to engage with our work. Men are part of the problem, not prostitution on its own."

Catherine Watt, Routes into Learning development officer, said she hoped that men would read A Rose, By Any Other Name to learn more about the issues faced by vulnerable women, "particularly those which drive them into prostitution".

Anne-Marie, 47, who wrote five short stories and poems about her 20 years of domestic abuse, cried when she saw her work in print.

She said: "I didn't realise that was me. It's the silence that is the most shocking thing about abuse and hopefully this book will help the general public find out more about the lives being wasted."

Harry Donaldson, the GMB's Scottish regional secretary, said: "A lot of these women are being exploited and our job is not about challenging the moral issue.

"We are quite happy to speak to Elaine and see if we can work jointly to help the lap-dancing industry move away from her concerns that it is a back door to prostitution."

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: Mhairi McAlpine on 12:20pm Sun 20 May 07
Prostitution is by definition violence against women. Drug addicted women, migrant women and adult survivors of child sexual abuse make up the vast majority of women in prositution. Those women enslaved by the industry, whether by traffickers, by addiction problems, by poverty, violent partners and pimps or poor mental health must be given support to escape.

The Scottish Socialist Party has been campaigning to end this industry which sees (primarily) women abused for mens entertainment. The key to this is targetting the demand for the industry and demand a sea change in male attitudes.

http://www.scottishs
ocialistparty.org.uk
/pdfs/pamphlet1_1_fi
nal.pdf

Posted by: BM, Glasgow on 12:31pm Sun 20 May 07
Mhairi McAlpine wrote:
Prostitution is by definition violence against women. Drug addicted women, migrant women and adult survivors of child sexual abuse make up the vast majority of women in prositution. Those women enslaved by the industry, whether by traffickers, by addiction problems, by poverty, violent partners and pimps or poor mental health must be given support to escape.

The Scottish Socialist Party has been campaigning to end this industry which sees (primarily) women abused for mens entertainment. The key to this is targetting the demand for the industry and demand a sea change in male attitudes.

http://www.scottishs
ocialistparty.org.uk
/pdfs/pamphlet1_1_fi
nal.pdf

Come on Mhairi, get real. What has the Scottish Socialist Party really been doing? Getting itself electorally annihilated with lurid court cases about the alleged sexual antics of its members? How can yours, of all parties, pretend to make a stand on sex crimes? How can your bunch of suicidal loonies influence anything? You no longer exist as far as sane voters are concerned!
Posted by: David Stevenson, Cambuslang on 9:39pm Sun 20 May 07
BM: why don't you read the SSP document and make some comments on the content rather than spouting irrelevant garbage?
Posted by: G on 10:06pm Sun 20 May 07
Socialism doesn't work! The USSR crumbled, the Chinese have now become more capitalistic because they were about to fall! Why would a doctor work for the same amount of money as a street sweeper? The idea of everyone getting the same amount of money and there not being any poor or rich is a good idea but it is only that, an idea, it just doesn't work. Socialism is one BIG step towards dictatorship, take a look at Venezuela or Ecuador, are their countries getting better or worse right now? What about Cuba!

Here it is the real Socialism slogan... Do you want the government to have everything and the people nothing? We'll tell you how to live, it'll be great! Don't vote or speak out against us though, or you might lose your job...
Posted by: BM, Glasgow on 11:29am Mon 21 May 07
David Stevenson wrote:
BM: why don\'t you read the SSP document and make some comments on the content rather than spouting irrelevant garbage?
Because the "garbage" is highly relevant and a matter of public record - and we haven't heard the last of it yet!
Read the SSP document? (Can one of you actually write?) I'd as soon read a document on law and order by a bank robber! You're has-beens, pseudo-Trots, yesterdays men, the loony fringe, a total irrelevance, a party which tore itself apart with the kind of antics you condemn, need I go on?
Posted by: David Stevenson, Cambuslang on 12:48pm Mon 21 May 07
BM: sure, keep on going. If you keep typing ransdomly you may finally get round to writing something pertinent to the issue.
Posted by: BM, Glasgow on 4:23pm Mon 21 May 07
Unlike the SSP who will never write anything pertinent. I thought they were Socialists who obeyed the will of the Proletariat. Well the Prols have delivered their verdict loud and clear! But perhaps you don't believe in the Will of the People when they tell you you're losers!
Posted by: David Stevenson, Cambuslang on 2:14pm Tue 22 May 07
BM: come on, you can do better than that surely. Try formulating an argument on the question in hand. I dare you.......
Posted by: Nadia, Brighton on 10:53pm Fri 25 May 07
How is it by definition violence against women . What about those who choose to do it. To be fair you have to admit it is a complex problem with multiple sides. Black and white views don't help. Check out http://www.prostitut
ionprocon.org
Add your comment
Name:
Email: *
Location:
**
Security Image. Registered site users are not required to enter Security Image Information.
 
 e.g. 123-123
Comment:
Please note: All HTML tags will be ignored.
Format Text:

 
By posting a comment, I confirm that I have read and agree to the terms of use. Comments are not moderated but we will react if anything that breaks the rules comes to our attention and we may delete inappropriate postings. Please treat other people with respect. You must not post anything that is abusive, indecent, unlawful or defamatory. Remember, you are personally liable for what you post on this site. If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us here.
* Your email address will not be displayed
** To avoid register now or login