Scots Gaelic is in peril. It is our duty to save it
Muriel Gray argues that multicultural Scotland should give priority to protecting our most endangered species, the native Gaels, before we start worrying about those who speak Punjabi, Urdu or Arabic.
Cultures Under Threat
In the minds of some, there seems to be a little confusion over what constitutes cultures under threat. The militant French speakers of Quebec, who lobbied aggressively for separation from the big, bad English-speaking Canada that sustains them, argued that they were “preserving their culture”. However, it is worth noting that their culture is being very efficiently preserved by 61 million people in a place called France. Similarly, the concern for “preserving” cultures like Punjabi, Urdu, and Arabic seems peculiar, considering they are robust, expanding, and still prevalent in their countries of origin. These languages and the associated customs and practices are not on the verge of extinction.
A Real Cultural Crisis
Scotland, on the other hand, has firsthand experience of a real cultural crisis. One of our own indigenous languages, Gaelic, is in peril as the population of native Gaelic speakers dwindles at an alarming rate. Specifically, the Western Isles, where Gaelic remains a mother tongue, are experiencing a terrifying decline in population. From 29,600 in 1991 to projected figures of 21,725 in 2018, the population is estimated to decline by 17%, while the Scottish average decline is only 2%. The focus should now be on how to prevent this tragic loss rather than the reasons behind it. If Gaelic language and culture disappear from the Western Isles, it will be lost forever.
Efforts to Preserve Gaelic
Over the past decade, the Gaelic Media Service, formerly known as the CCG, has dedicated efforts to preserving the language through the commissioning of Gaelic television programs. Some aspects of this initiative have been successful, particularly in current affairs, arts strands, and children’s programs that appeal to a wider audience beyond Gaelic speakers. Young children are naturally picking up the language from these shows. However, funding for this endeavor, which was never index linked, has been decreasing, resulting in reduced broadcasting hours and scheduling inconveniences.
The Need for a Dedicated Gaelic Channel
The Milne Report, a study commissioned to explore the future of Gaelic broadcasting, has proposed the establishment of a dedicated Gaelic channel. This solution is not only the most sensible forward step but is now absolutely essential. While the Scottish Executive shows sensitivity to the needs of the crisis-torn Western Isles, the concern lies in determining who will run the digital channel. Suggestions of established broadcasters like SMG or the BBC running it on behalf of the Gaels could be problematic. To ensure the channel’s long-term commercial viability and direct benefit to the population of the Western Isles, it must be operated by Gaelic speakers themselves. Despite modesty and an aversion to self-promotion, a visit to Stornoway revealed impressive existing media facilities and local talent.
The Canary in the Mineshaft
It is crucial to recognize that the future of the Western Isles and the Gaelic language should be a top priority. The survival of Gaelic represents an integral part of Scotland's national culture. Without proactive efforts to preserve it, we risk losing something that can never be recreated. Therefore, the establishment of a dedicated Gaelic channel, run by Gaels with complete financial and creative autonomy, is necessary. Such a channel would not only benefit Gaelic speakers but also attract wider viewership and contribute to the preservation of Scotland's cultural heritage.
Hotels in Scotland
While focusing on the preservation of Scotland's cultural heritage, it is essential to ensure that visitors have comfortable accommodation options when exploring the country. Scotland offers a wide range of hotels catering to different preferences and budgets.
1. Luxury Hotels
For travelers seeking a luxurious experience, Scotland boasts several high-end hotels known for their exceptional service, stunning locations, and world-class amenities. From historic castle hotels to modern city establishments, these luxury accommodations provide a lavish retreat for discerning guests.
2. Boutique Hotels
Those looking for a more intimate and personalized stay can choose from a variety of boutique hotels scattered across Scotland. These charming, often individually designed hotels offer character, style, and a unique atmosphere that reflects the local culture and heritage.
3. Budget-Friendly Hotels
Travelers on a budget need not worry as Scotland offers numerous affordable hotels that provide comfortable rooms and essential amenities. These budget-friendly options allow visitors to explore the country without breaking the bank, ensuring a memorable stay without compromising on quality.