Cows destroyed, imports banned ... foot-and-mouth is back in Britain
Report by James Cusick
AN URGENT independent review of biosecurity measures at an animal
research laboratory close to the outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease at a
farm in Surrey, was ordered by the government last night after it was
discovered that a special strain of the virus which had been recently
manufactured in a batch at the lab, and which is not routinely found in
animals, is the same strain as those found in the infected cattle.
The Institute of Animal Health (IAH) laboratory is only a few miles from the
farm at Wanborough, where 64 cattle were slaughtered and their carcas
ses
incinerated yesterday. The cattle were identified as potentially suffering
from foot-and-mouth late on Thursday.
When the outbreak was verified on Friday by government veterinary
inspectors, a nationwide ban on livestock movement and a ban on beef exports
was ordered, sparking panic that Britain was on the verge of another
foot-and-mouth epidemic. Identifying the specific strain of the disease
to
help identify the source of the outbreak and to begin vaccine manufacture
was one of the priorities ordered by Defra scientists, the department
responsible for rural affairs.
Late last night, the strain of the specific foot-and-mouth virus was
confirmed as 01 BFS67, similar to the virus isolated in the 1967 outbreak in
the UK.
The 01 strain is similar to types used in international laboratories
researching the disease and is also used in the production of specialist
animal vaccines.
The Pirbright site is shared by the IAH and the pharmaceutical company
Merial Animal Health, which makes an
internationally marketed range of animal vaccines for both livestock and
pets.
In a statement from Defra, the presence of the strain at the Pirbright
facility and in the Wanborough herd was confirmed as being the same. 'This
strain is present at the IAH and was used in a batch manufactured in July
2007 by the Merial facility. On a precautionary basis, Merial has agreed to
voluntarily halt vaccine production.'
After a day of promises by the government to react quickly and decisively to
limit the spread of foot-and-mouth, the government's chief veterinary
officer, Dr Debby Reynolds, ordered a new exclusion zone with a 10km radius
which encompasses both the infected farm at Wanborough and the research lab.
Although the linkage of the strain in the infected animals with the batch
manufactured last month at Pirbright removes some of the panic and fears of
the outbreak, the discovery doesn't limit the potential fears that it cou
ld
have spread beyond the Surrey farm.
Last night, weather experts at the Met Office were studying wind charts that
could explain how the virus was carried from the lab to the farm.
The review of biosecurity measures at Pirbright will be undertaken by
professor Brian Spratt of Imperial College in London.
Defra last night were trying not to sound overconfident that the crisis had
passed due to the swift identification of the strain and its origins. 'Th
is
incident remains at an early stage. It is too soon to reach any firm
conclusions. All other precautionary measures announced yesterday will
remain in place.'
For Britain's farmers, Defra's caution is a mixture of both good and bad
news: good in the sense that a rock-solid link has been found quickly, and
bad that the tough regime of livestock movement bans, and export bans,
remains in force.
News of the link between the lab and the outbreak will, however, ease fears
on international markets that Britain's livestock products were about to
experience the trauma suffered in 2001 when millions of cattle were
slaughtered and burned in an epidemic.
Crucial continental markets will have to be convinced that the outbreak can
now be limited. Environmental authorities in Germany have already begun
inspecting cattle imported from Britain over the past month. French
authorities have carried out similar inspections.
Ireland has also banned the import of all live animals, fresh meat and
non-pasteurised milk from Britain, while the United States has widened
cattle and sheep bans already in place to cover all imports of pork.
With the Pirbright link not known, the prime minister Gordon Brown cancelled
his holiday in Dorset, believing he had another large-scale crisis on his
hands on the back of the recent floods. He promised: 'We will be doing,
night and day, everything in our power to make sure that what happens,
happens quickly and happens decisively in a way that can reassure people
that everything is being done.' The environment secretary, Hilary B
enn, also
cut short his holiday in Italy to oversee his department.
The government's response, as it was with the recent terrorist attacks in
London and Glasgow, looked to be inclusive and involve the main political
parties.
During a 50-minute morning meeting of the government's civil emergency
committee, Cobra, Scotland's first minister Alex Salmond, and the
Executive's rural affairs minister Richard Lochhead took part in
discussions.
Following the Cobra meeting, Brown made separate telephone calls to the
Conservatives' leader David Cameron and to the Liberal Democrat leader Sir
Menzies Campbell. A one-to-one telephone call was also made to Salmond,
where they discussed the initial measures to combat the spread of the virus.
In a marked contrast to the way the government hesitated in the ear
ly stages
of the devastating 2001 outbreak, the government wasted little time
yesterday in announcing a UK-wide ban on the movement of all livestock.The
ban will remain in force till it is confirmed that the biosecurity failures
at Pirbright have not gone beyond Wanborough.
Promising to use the lessons learned in the outbreak of 2001, Defra said it
would set up a national disease centre in London, as part of contingency
plans which early last night looked more like a long-term action plan than
measures to deal with a limited problem.
But the swift identification of the strain and its link to the nearby
research and vaccine lab, will inevitably ease fears in the agriculture
sector.
Along with the biosecurity review, the Health and Safety Executive are to
lead an investigation into the procedures which were followed by researchers
at the IAH & Merial facility.
In a statement tonight, Merial Animal Health said: 'Following the recent
outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease at a farm near Guildford, Merial can
confirm that it has suspended virus production at its vaccine centre in
Pirbright.
'The decision to suspend production has been taken in full consultation w
ith
Defra and will enable Defra to carry out a thorough investigation into all
possible sources of this outbreak.'