Home
September 06, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
The new scandal
Labour in meltdown: Part two
Why was identity of potential Wendy donor switched?

WENDY ALEXANDER is at the centre of another funding row after it emerged that the name of a prominent businessman listed as a donor was different to the name her campaign team intended to give to the Electoral Commission.

WENDYGATE

The lies
Paul Hutcheon

Blair's legacy?
By James Cusick, Westminster Editor

The donors
Who gave to Wendy's campaign ... and the members of the team who brought in the cash

The questions a probe would ask
By Paul Hutcheon

How the Sunday Herald broke the story

Salmond: Ban English cash from Scottish polls
By Paul Hutcheon

Why Wendy has no choice but to go
By Iain Macwhirter

Labour's friend in the north
By Torcuil Crichton

Political funding reform? Parties should just respect the law
What we think

Donor scandal could kill all trust in Labour's leaders
By Iain Macwhirter

The Labour leader's secret donor list, which has been exclusively obtained by the Sunday Herald, states that Moir Lockhead, the chief executive of transport giant First Group, was pencilled in for a £995 donation.

But the column reserved for the name to be supplied to the Electoral Commission was switched to John Lyons, the ex-Labour MP and one-time consultant to First Group.

Even if the cash was not banked, the list suggests a clear intent to give the Commission false information.

In another twist, a spokesman for Lockhead denies he made any donation to the campaign. And John Lyons told the Sunday Herald that he had no idea why his name had been included in that way in the list.

He said he had been asked by David Whitton, the MSP for Strathkelvin and Bearsden and treasurer of the Alexander campaign, to approach Moir Lockhead to discuss a donation to the campaign. "I told David Whitton that would be a waste of time and that Moir would never give a political donation,'' said Lyons last night. Lyons said he agreed to give his his own donation and did so some time later.

The row follows Alexander's admission that her Labour leadership campaign accepted a £950 donation from tax exile Paul Green.

The secret donor list makes clear the cash came from Green, whose address was given as "St Martin, Jersey". Alexander's campaign then told the Electoral commission it had come from a UK company.

The same list shows how Lockhead was pencilled in for a donation of £995 - £5 below the threshold for public declaration.

But in the column marked "Name/ address for Elect Comm purpose", Lockhead's name was changed to John Lyons. The action point column said of the donation: "On way via John Lyons 11/10."

Lyons was the Labour MP for Strathkelvin and Bearsden, but lost his seat at the 2005 general election. After his defeat, he became a consultant to First Group on trade union issues.

The political "contact" for the donation is named on the list as "David", which the Sunday Herald understands is shorthand for David Whitton. Whitton's register of interest states that First Group was one of his clients when he ran a PR firm before becoming an MSP.

At a UK level, Labour has endured an avalanche of criticism after accepting cash from property developer David Abrahams through other people.

Lockhead is not known to have made any political donations before, so it would be a surprise for his name to appear in the "donor" section of Alexander's list.

According to the company's website, First Group is a UK firm with revenues of more than £5 billion a year, employing more than 135,000 staff throughout Britain and North America.

While there is no record of Lockhead ever making a donation, the owner of a rival transport group is a well-known SNP supporter. Brian Souter, who runs Stagecoach, donated about £500,000 to the Nationalists in the run-up to the May election.

A spokesman for Lockhead said: "He has not supported Wendy Alexander's campaign."

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: Jimbo on 12:27am Sun 2 Dec 07
Why does Hutcheon find it necessary to bring Brian Souter's name and the SNP into this story of Labour corruption?

Is he somehow trying to subliminally suggest that Souter's donation was tainted?
Posted by: Duncan, East Kilbride. on 12:31am Sun 2 Dec 07
Labour has still not accepted that they are no longer in charge and their hegemoney has gone foreve. They just cannot behave in the way they have been getting away with for decades in Scotland. They are naturally dependent on corruption and graft to get their way, but it is finished.
Absolutely wonderfull. Scotland is having a spring clean, what a great feeling.
GOD BLESS ALEX SALMOND.
Posted by: ALBA, LEGION on 12:36am Sun 2 Dec 07
Mr Hutcheon,

I can only guess at the quandry of being a life-long political apologist of the Scottish Branch of London Labour and truth.

Please stick to the truth. Set Scotland Free.

Posted by: Wullie, Aberdeen on 12:39am Sun 2 Dec 07
Wendy Alexander is a thick Glaswegian. What do you expect .
Posted by: doonhamer on 12:47am Sun 2 Dec 07
Dead Leader Walking

Dead Party Waiting
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 12:52am Sun 2 Dec 07
I agree with Jimbo about the comment quoted belowWhy does Hutcheon find it necessary to bring Brian Souter's name into it?It seems utterly gratuitous.

Wendy Alexander is a thick Glaswegian.You didn't need to add her city of residence, Wullie. It weakens the power of your remark.

Once a wee bauchle, always a wee bauchle.
Posted by: Mike, Edinburgh on 12:54am Sun 2 Dec 07
Wullie from Aberdeen, you are for some reason trying to discredit the people of Glasgow. This is a campaign you have been promoting for a number of months now. As a Sctsman I find your continued attacks on my countrymen offensive in the extreme. Aberdeen, Glasgow, Edinburgh ,Inverness, Dundee and every other part of Scotland is populated by my fellow countrymen. It makes absolutely no difference where they are from in Scotland.

You are obviously some little grub from another country who needs to give it away by concentrating on your own problems. I suppose you just dont get it in that we dont really care what party one supports, or what team they support or what colour or religion they are. All that really matters is they are Scottish in their heart and love this country, so **** off.
Posted by: Glesca Calling on 12:59am Sun 2 Dec 07
Good Morning Wullie, and a fine day to you up in Aberdeen.

Ken its raining here in Glasgow and Wee Wendy will be sleeping in her bed tucked up tight in the knowledge that its ok to tell lies, take illegal donations and etc.

Alternatively I wonder if shes dreaming aboot a knock on the door from the Glesga Polis or whether she thinks she has that covered.

All her pals down south think they do - but you never know the Polis here might be honest and above political influence.

Time will tell - and now what aboot big Trump?
Posted by: DJ, Glasgow on 1:03am Sun 2 Dec 07
Mike, Edinburgh.

Well said.
Posted by: Jimbo on 1:12am Sun 2 Dec 07
Wullie wrote:
Wendy Alexander is a thick Glaswegian. What do you expect .
Aye Wullie,

in my youth in the East-end of Glasgow, we would have referred to her as a 'wee herry' and a 'wee nyaff chancer'.

I enjoy your posts Wullie, they make me Laugh.
Posted by: John J. Sheridan, Z'ha'dum on 1:15am Sun 2 Dec 07
Am I the only person who is enjoying this whole thing immensely?
I hope not, I would hate to think that the subversion of decent politics, fraud and lying to anyone who is within earshot was now so commonplace that I can feel this good about the consequences.

I am still feeling a guilty pleasure in watching this shower coming to the grief they so richly deserve.

Oh the joy......I am sorry....oh the joy....
Posted by: Yok Finney, Ross-shire on 1:15am Sun 2 Dec 07
The money wasn't given to the party it was given to meme.

So she wrote a thank you letter, as I would too.

It's time to ditch all sentimentality about the Labour Party as that they now represent in any way the working people of Scotland.

The Holyrood Paliament is our opportunity waiting for ? a dynamic ?

It's waiting for the home truths of Scotland to get serious debate!
Posted by: Wullie, Aberdeen on 1:16am Sun 2 Dec 07
Mike from Edinbugh, calm down, relax, have a cup of ovaltine and take up knitting. It will help to get rid of all the tension and stress.
Posted by: Functus, Edinburgh on 1:19am Sun 2 Dec 07
Brian Souter's donation - announced by Alex Salmond at the podium of an SNP conference.

Labour's donations - hidden donations from illegal sources.

That's the difference.
Posted by: John J. Sheridan, Z'ha'dum on 1:27am Sun 2 Dec 07
Wullie wrote:
Mike from Edinbugh, calm down, relax, have a cup of ovaltine and take up knitting. It will help to get rid of all the tension and stress.
It appears to me that Mike is very relaxed, coherent, unencumbered and sane.
All the attributes missing from your stupidities.
Posted by: Harry Grant, Edinburgh on 1:37am Sun 2 Dec 07
Wullie wrote:
Mike from Edinbugh, calm down, relax, have a cup of ovaltine and take up knitting. It will help to get rid of all the tension and stress.
Well said Wullie. Your insightful comments on Glasgow are hilarious.
Posted by: Jimbo on 1:38am Sun 2 Dec 07
From the Scotland on Sunday..............
.

MSP Charlie Gordon, has now admitted he earlier supported Paul Green for an unspecified honour.

"Green's spokeswoman last night confirmed he had been in line for an honour and claimed that four other Labour figures were involved in writing letters of recommendation."

http://scotlandonsun
day.scotsman.com/ind
ex.cfm?id=1883512007


So even after the cash for peerages scandal they're still at it.
Posted by: LEGION, ALBA on 1:44am Sun 2 Dec 07
Functus wrote:
Brian Souter's donation - announced by Alex Salmond at the podium of an SNP conference. Labour's donations - hidden donations from illegal sources. That's the difference.
The difference is that the Scottish Branch of London Labour would prefer to be outwith Scots Law.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 1:53am Sun 2 Dec 07
Jimbo Quotes The SoS
MSP Charlie Gordon has now admitted he earlier supported Paul Green for an unspecified honour.
That will be Order of the Grand Loser.

PC Plod will duly note it connects the antics of Labour North with Labour South.
Posted by: Angus, Aberdeen on 2:43am Sun 2 Dec 07
Wullie

Ya dafty.....is this the very same Aberdeen that you are so proud of

http://news.bbc.co.u
k/1/hi/scotland/2900
791.stm

"The first NHS facility for crack users is due to open later this year in Aberdeen, where addicts can currently wait several months for treatment due to a lack of resources"

Ha ha ha Glasgow get the Commonwealth games and you get the crack dens....try again ya nugget....! LOL ma sides are burstin'
Posted by: David Young, Albany on 5:01am Sun 2 Dec 07
In the long-term, this will be good for the Labour Party. It will have to change from the corrupt practices of the past and reinvent itself for the future, returning to the principles of Keir Hardie would be a good start. He'll be birling in his grave at what Labour has become.
Posted by: donald, glasgow on 6:16am Sun 2 Dec 07
Oor Wullie, we have seen some of the Cooncillors claiming to represent the good fowk o' Aiberdeen. Lots of other nations will have no hesitation in accepting a golden egg from Donald Trump, or whovever.
Posted by: Duncan, Forfar on 7:54am Sun 2 Dec 07
So the wee lassie with the big mooth is a crook! who woulda guessed it??

Run the scoundrels oot of toon
Posted by: Tam, Dundee on 7:57am Sun 2 Dec 07
never thought i would say this but that glib jumped up little s**t McConnel is actually starting to look like a good guy compared the the dipS**ts that replaced him
Posted by: Paul, Pailsey on 8:32am Sun 2 Dec 07
Wendy, your house is falling down; go now and sell your integrity with your world class mind to private business.
Posted by: Trendy wendy, Glasgow on 8:44am Sun 2 Dec 07
These people are just trash. End of story. As for Wendy, what does she look like? The wee pouting lips and so on? They called her Donald Dewars poodle. She looks like a severe brown nose. Has she ever had a real job?
Posted by: nicky tams, the mains on 8:44am Sun 2 Dec 07
wullie ,as a native o the north east, i and many like me are sick of your comments about glaswegians. If anyone is thick it is you for beleiving that your childish comments will have any effect.
Posted by: Disgusted Dorothy, Glasgow on 8:51am Sun 2 Dec 07
John.I'm with you!It is highly entertaining stuff!
Each day brings more hilarity through revelation and more sumbling apologies and excuses.
Get intae them Herald!
And I agree that mentioning Brain Souter was unneccessary,everyon
e knows that he backed the SNP and by how much!
Posted by: BM, Glasgow on 9:11am Sun 2 Dec 07
Jimbo wrote:
Why does Hutcheon find it necessary to bring Brian Souter's name and the SNP into this story of Labour corruption?

Is he somehow trying to subliminally suggest that Souter's donation was tainted?
Exactly. Brian Souter is a British elector and taxpayer, making large but entirely legal and transparent donations, as he is perfectly entitled to do by law. Everything is legal and in the open, so why mention it in connection with story about corruption?
Posted by: Geordie, Brussels on 9:37am Sun 2 Dec 07
Paul wrote:
Wendy, your house is falling down; go now and sell your integrity with your world class mind to private business.
Noooooooooooooooooo!


As a nationalist I respectfully disagree. I hope Wendy survives this crisis and goes on to lead Scottish New Labour for a long, long time.

WENDY MUST STAY!
Posted by: Heederum-Hoderum, High Horse on 10:05am Sun 2 Dec 07
Harry Grant wrote:
Wullie wrote: Mike from Edinbugh, calm down, relax, have a cup of ovaltine and take up knitting. It will help to get rid of all the tension and stress.
Well said Wullie. Your insightful comments on Glasgow are hilarious.
HARRY G

Insightful??? Whit?? Insightful??
Are ye daft Sir?????
Posted by: William O, Glasgow on 10:05am Sun 2 Dec 07
Wullie from Aberdeen. I'm a Scot, currently living in Glasgow and having travelled extensively in work and leisure feel qualified to feel revulsion at your post expressing your bias on Glasgow and it's occupants. I've met Scots from all over Scotland and only the usual banter between the different cities has been encountered, much of it quite amusing. Maybe it's time you travelled a bit and broadened that mind you think you have. Please note that Mike from Edinburgh speaks for thousands of us who find your type and attitude very anti-Scottish. Please try a re-think and remember that the Saltire covers us all.
Posted by: pehman, sussex on 10:21am Sun 2 Dec 07
Miles of words from dozens of reporters

Not a cheep from the boy's in blue ?

WHATS GOING ON IS ANYTHING BEING DONE ABOUT THIS ???
Posted by: CJM, west lothian on 10:49am Sun 2 Dec 07
Will our Prime Minister be forced to answer this crook in parliment,will she have the brass neck to turn up at FMQ's ,wiil the POLICE arrest her or NOT, are labour finished in Scotland.
The law on donations was fine untill the labour party broke it, by changeing the law it won't stop it being broken so enforceing the existing laws are the only answer, jailing those who break these laws is the answer, arrest them now.
SCOTLAND IS WATCHING OUR LEGAL SYSTem.
Posted by: iang, glasgow on 11:20am Sun 2 Dec 07
Wullie wrote:
Wendy Alexander is a thick Glaswegian. What do you expect .
Please Wullie, Wendy is not from Glasgow she is from Paisley. If you are going attempt to be insulting you may as well get the insults right.
Posted by: Colin B, Bearsden on 11:22am Sun 2 Dec 07
False accounting can now be added to the indictment

Lets hope the Crown Office have the sense to keep this case away from the Labour Supporting john Beckett(sacked as Solicitor general for his bias )
Posted by: Tartan Tory, Bishopbriggs on 11:27am Sun 2 Dec 07
Jimbo wrote:
Why does Hutcheon find it necessary to bring Brian Souter's name and the SNP into this story of Labour corruption? Is he somehow trying to subliminally suggest that Souter's donation was tainted?
Why not ?

Its so true and why the surprise since Wee Exk and his pals hand out the big franchise deals ?
Posted by: Tartan Tory, Bishopbriggs on 11:33am Sun 2 Dec 07
Jimbo wrote:
Why does Hutcheon find it necessary to bring Brian Souter\\\\\\\\\\\\'s name and the SNP into this story of Labour corruption? Is he somehow trying to subliminally suggest that Souter\\\\\\\\\\\\'s donation was tainted?
Why not ?

Its true and why the surprise since Wee Eck and his pals hand out the big franchise deals ?
Posted by: PaulB, Glasgow on 11:42am Sun 2 Dec 07
Excellent article!
I hope this whole sorry affair will lead to the routing of the corruption with the Labour ranks. From a local perspective hopefully the "Glasgow Labour Mafia" and their cronies, who the Herald seem to avoid investigating, will get their just rewards.
Posted by: Teresa Green on 12:25pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Tartan Tory wrote:
Jimbo wrote: Why does Hutcheon find it necessary to bring Brian Souter\\\\\\\\\\\\'s name and the SNP into this story of Labour corruption? Is he somehow trying to subliminally suggest that Souter\\\\\\\\\\\\'s donation was tainted?
Why not ? Its true and why the surprise since Wee Eck and his pals hand out the big franchise deals ?
You do have to laugh at Labour's desperation. While we are this subject why did First Group get the Scotrail franchise? Who worked for them just before getting the franchise. None other than the then Transport Minister Nicol Stephen - just a coincidence?
Posted by: observer on 12:57pm Sun 2 Dec 07
I wondered what had happened to John Lyons, he used to be a full time official for UNISON, then he morphed into a Labour MSP, then was put out due to clever tactical voting, and then morphed into a ''consultant'' advising on trade union matters. Interesting career. I wonder what he's up to now ?
Posted by: greig, glasgow on 1:05pm Sun 2 Dec 07
hello to teresa green,away and bile yer heed.you and your type our now history.by the way give my regards to eck whatch.
Posted by: canofworms, Glasgow on 1:07pm Sun 2 Dec 07
I so love your wee asides, they provide such wonderful snippets of info. Thank you for another one!
Posted by: greig, glasgow on 1:09pm Sun 2 Dec 07
so sorry teresa i ment the tartan tory.
Posted by: canofworms, Glasgow on 1:10pm Sun 2 Dec 07
sorry, that was to Observer.
Posted by: greig, glasgow on 1:12pm Sun 2 Dec 07
do you like my spellin,so sorry but i was eduk ated by a layber guvermint
Posted by: P Davidson, Glasgow on 1:15pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Perhaps the reason First Group did not donate to Wendy was because her brother was no longer the Minister for Transport.
Wendy broke the law, simple as that, so she must resign at let Scottish Politics show the rest of the UK that Scots believe the law must be upheld regardless of who you are.
Posted by: Retired...........bu t still switched on, Fed Up To The Teeth on 1:23pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Tartan Tory wrote:
Jimbo wrote: Why does Hutcheon find it necessary to bring Brian Souter\\\\\\\\\\\\'s name and the SNP into this story of Labour corruption? Is he somehow trying to subliminally suggest that Souter\\\\\\\\\\\\'s donation was tainted?
Why not ? Its true and why the surprise since Wee Eck and his pals hand out the big franchise deals ?
TARTAN TORY
.and of course, you have EVIDENCE of misdeeds by the SNP and Brian Souter then Sir?? Hmmm........thought not !!
Posted by: Jennifer Tailya, Itching to get there on 2:25pm Sun 2 Dec 07
They used to have a 'Wendy House' within the secure unit at the Bar L. Should come in handy.
Posted by: dws on 3:45pm Sun 2 Dec 07
This is beyond party politics, it's corruption, pure and simple. It's illegal, it's irrefutable and it stinks.
The police investigation should proceed as soon as possible and this cancer in the body politic of our country should be excised.
Posted by: A Scottish Voice, IOM on 4:09pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Credit where credit due.

Well done the Herald Team !!!!

But more importantly... Please keep up this standard of investigative journalism.

Scotland needs at least one Newspaper to tell the truth..... and nothing but the truth.

Favour no-one.... just tell the truth!
Posted by: dws on 4:27pm Sun 2 Dec 07
A Scottish Voice wrote:
Credit where credit due. Well done the Herald Team !!!! But more importantly... Please keep up this standard of investigative journalism. Scotland needs at least one Newspaper to tell the truth..... and nothing but the truth. Favour no-one.... just tell the truth!
I couldn't agree more.
Posted by: canofworms, Glagow on 4:40pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Dearie me let's not get carried away you lot. This is the same Herald which has on it's payroll a number who have gone to great lengths to keep backing Labour, even after the election in May! They didn't do any investigating either, all this info was passed to them by an insider at Holyrood. So let's hang fire with the "Hurrah for the Herald" stuff until we see if they are going to put on their front page tomorrow morning "ALEXANDER SHOULD RESIGN NOW!"
Posted by: dws on 5:10pm Sun 2 Dec 07
As reported on another thread, Lothian and Borders Police are now involved.
Posted by: nicky celino, glasgow on 5:33pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Wullie fae aberdeen bit of a arse mmmm
Posted by: Steve Read on 6:20pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Wendy dear, I hope you've put a bit away for you'll no make much on the streets
Posted by: Victor Smith on 7:58pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Is it true?
I understand that Wendy Alexander ( who spent a short, very short, period as a Scottish Labour Party Leader) has spent all day Sunday digging away in the garden.

No, she was not doing it to relieve the stress of the last few days, but, it is said, she seems to have lost her soul!

I am now informed that, even though it is now 1930hrs she is still searching, although many are telling her it's a real 'Lost Cause!'

When 'Truth and Honesty' are no more - like the soul, when lost, is lost forever - regardless!

Time to go - and with great haste!

Perhaps she should try her hand at the EU - (a wonderful home for political wasters, as she seems an ideal candidate with the standard of qualifications she has shown over the last few days - and they have a much larger 'trough' than Westminster and Holyrood combined, and there are many of the same ilk in permanent residence, apparently all without a worry in the World - as yet!
Posted by: Ronald, Glasgow on 8:13pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Good idea Vic! Perhaps oor wee Wendy can join that other crook, Peter"Mandy" Mandelson as
an EU official.
Once paracite scumbags like Alexander get their snouts in the money trough it seems that
little can be done to get rid of the porkers!
Posted by: James, Lanarkshire on 8:59pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Even if she manages to duck out of this situation, how can she possibly stand up in Parliament now and have any credibility. Can you imagine her at some time in the future trying to have a debate on party donations,or on any other matter? The government will wipe the floor with her. It will be an interesting First Minister's questions this week if she is still leader.
Posted by: John Leven, Leven Fife on 9:44pm Sun 2 Dec 07
James Lanarkshire

I have posted a Question on Brian Taylors blog.

Will Alex Salmond get a telling off from the Presiding Officer if he falls about with laughter when Alexander asks him a question about Honesty, openness or transparency.

I think AS will surgery to get the smile off his face this week.
Posted by: James, Lanarkshire on 11:40pm Sun 2 Dec 07
Alex Salmond was interviewed by Andrew Neil on BBC News 24 Hardtalk tonight. An excellent interview and quite enlightening about where he is coming from on all of the policy issues!
And no mention of Labour's woes.
Add your comment
Name:
Email: *
Location:
**
Security Image. Registered site users are not required to enter Security Image Information.
 
 e.g. 123-123
Comment:
Please note: All HTML tags will be ignored.
Format Text:

 
By posting a comment, I confirm that I have read and agree to the terms of use. Comments are not moderated but we will react if anything that breaks the rules comes to our attention and we may delete inappropriate postings. Please treat other people with respect. You must not post anything that is abusive, indecent, unlawful or defamatory. Remember, you are personally liable for what you post on this site. If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us here.
* Your email address will not be displayed
** To avoid register now or login