Home
May 17, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
WENDY HIT BY NEW REVELATIONS
* Secret donor list was sent from Alexander's office
* Holyrood rules broken by using MSP facilities for Party fundraising
* Third inquiry to be launched, this time by Parliamentary Standards Committee
The trail that goes to the heart of Holyrood
By Paul Hutcheon, Scottish Political Editor

THE SECRET list of donors that showed Wendy Alexander's team knew four weeks ago about a legally suspect donation from a Jersey tycoon was sent directly from the Labour leader's office.

The Sunday Herald understands the list of fundraisers was circulated by her office using the parliamentary email system - a link that ties Alexander to the document.

It also suggests the Labour leader's campaign was using MSP facilities for party fundraising purposes - an activity that is explicitly against Holyrood rules.

The revelation comes as Alexander faces a disciplinary probe after the parliament's Standards Commissioner, Dr Jim Dyer, received a complaint about her non-disclosure of donations on her MSP's register of interests.

Alexander managed to avoid declaring any of her donors to Holyrood after each contribution was sent to her campaign, rather than to the leader herself. This has prompted an SNP researcher to call on Dyer to investigate Alexander's failure to register the donations.

The researcher's letter to the standards commissioner states: "Given that Ms Alexander was the donee for a number of payments of more than £520, I believe she may have breached regulations on receipt and declaration of gifts."

The move follows Alexander's admission that her campaign to become Labour's Holyrood leader was partly financed by an illegal £950 donation from Jersey tax exile Paul Green.

Alexander's campaign team defended her by saying she first knew the donation was a personal, rather than a corporate, contribution, on November 29. However, last week this newspaper revealed that Alexander's secret donor list, dated November 5, included Green's Jersey address in the column reserved for the purpose of Electoral Commission registration.

The document, which listed Alexander's husband Brian Ashcroft as its "author", also questioned the legality of the donation. In other words, Team Alexander was aware of the donation's dodgy status weeks ago.

The list also revealed that four members of Team Alexander - Tom McCabe, treasurer David Whitton, Pauline McNeill and Jackie Baillie - were listed as "contacts" for pulling in donations of £995, or £5 less than the minimum requiring public registration.

The Sunday Herald now understands the secret donor list was circulated from Alexander's office on the parliamentary email system. The revelation makes it difficult for the Labour leader to argue that she was not aware of the document's contents.

The parliament's MSPs' Allowances Code makes clear that publicly funded facilities should not be used for party ends, laying down that "Parliamentary stationery and office equipment must not be used for party purposes." It adds: "Premises, or the relevant part of premises, acquired as Parliamentary offices, shall not be used as a base for canvassing or election campaigning, or any party activity related to elections."

The revelations in last week's issue of the Sunday Herald are believed to have led Alexander to consider resigning, a decision that was avoided after she received supportive phone calls from the prime pinister and her brother Douglas, the secretary of state for international development.

Alexander instead put out a statement in which she insisted there had been no "intentional" wrongdoing on her part. Her week then involved dealing with the numerous political tremors that followed the initial Green revelations.

On Tuesday, Green's accusation that Team Alexander was guilty of "gross mismanagement" seemed to complement a weekend of shocking headlines. But hours later, Alexander read out a well-received statement to the media at Holyrood and took questions from the press.

In particular, her revelation that correspondence existed between her and Charlie Gordon, in which she had questioned the Green donation, which the Glasgow Cathcart MSP had solicited, strengthened her position.

On Thursday, a sober performance at first minister's questions was followed by health minister Nicola Sturgeon mocking her in a debate on the constitution. It was an uncomfortable, rather than disastrous, day.

At the same time, a parallel story about the other key player in the Green scandal, Gordon, was also unfolding. The Labour MSP told journalists on Tuesday that he would make a statement on his "political future" later in the week. But reports he was to quit as an MSP proved to be unfounded after he issued a bland statement on Friday stating he was intending to stay.

A subplot to the drama is the increasing paranoia and feeling of mistrust within the Labour camp. Whitton was said to have been unamused at the suggestion he might be legally liable for the dodgy donation and Iain Bundred, the Labour fixer sent up from London to help the embattled Labour leader, was known to have displeased one senior member of Team Alexander last week.

First Minister Alex Salmond and Sir Alistair Graham, the former chairman of Westminster's Committee on Standards in Public Life, have said Alexander should quit her post while she attempts to clear her name.

A spokesman for Alexander, speaking about the donor list that was sent from the leader's office, said that "due process is under way and should be respected".

On the specific point about using Holyrood facilities for fundraising purposes, Jackie Baillie said: "If any of those who were helping out on the campaign has committed a minor breach in this way, then we are sincerely sorry."

SNP MSP Alex Neil said: "This gives the lie to the idea that they didn't know the donation was illegal until two Thursdays ago, and it shows a level of crassness of judgement that is beyond the pale.

"Using the Holyrood email for this is also against the parliament's rules. I don't think taxpayers will be very happy that their money and resources are being used for internal elections to the Labour party."

Deputy Scottish Tory leader Murdo Fraser said: "Wendy Alexander's defence throughout this whole process has been that she did not intentionally break the law. However, that defence looks increasingly incredible, given that there is a clear link between her personally and this document, which queried the permissibility of Green's donation.

"She has to come clean and give a full public explanation of her entire involvement with this donation."

Paul Green, meanwhile, is tending his business interests at home in Jersey. A horseracing enthusiast, he has received the official registration for his latest horse. Its name? No More Donations.

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: LEGION, ALBA on 12:38am Sun 9 Dec 07
http://www.scottishp
olitics.org/

For the real Wendygate story and other unbiased Scots political reporting check out this excellent web-site....

...WARNING:Scottish Branch of London Labour should not watch alone..........
Posted by: Mrs I P Knightly on 12:40am Sun 9 Dec 07
As Oscar Wilde said - if you keep telling the truth, sooner or later you will be found out.
Posted by: On the fence, Edinburgh on 12:52am Sun 9 Dec 07
Must admit, i'm looking forward to finding out who the journo's source on this is. Presumably, if the documents sent to the Sunday Herald are to be used as evidence, the source would have to be disclosed to prove their validity and render them admissable? Don't know if he'd like that much - he seemed awfy defensive about it on the Politics Show last week.
Posted by: On the fence, Edinburgh on 12:54am Sun 9 Dec 07
Forgot to add, if he does reveal the source, it's civil war in Labour for sure.
Posted by: Richard Quinn on 12:55am Sun 9 Dec 07
All this mess because the Labour Party was worried about the SNP getting money from Sean Connery who lived abroad.

So they thought that they would change the rules, which they did.

Now it turns out that they cannot understand or abide by their own rules, and in opposition they have deprived themselves of more money, and Wendy is complaining that she doesn't have enough money to run her department.

What favours did Charlie Gordon do for Paul Green that he writes two cheques out for him, just for the asking ?, and at a figure that doesn't have to be reported.

You just couldn't make it up.

I didn't intentionally break the law !

Such sheer incompetence.

And they want to run the Country !.

What's the betting that the Labour Party will get off with it again ?.

Now there are more revelations that the Labour Party have broken more Holyrood rules in using MSP@s facilities for fundraising.

When the people in charge of justice are selected by them, rather than elected, then we will always have this kind of problem with accountability.

Ron Gould’s Report wasn't good enough for them, so they should be sent to jail if found guilty, as it's the only way that they will learn a lesson.
Either because they are so thick that they can't understand their own rules, or they are so arrogant that they know that they will get away with it again.

This is Mis-Representation of the People Act, as Gordon Brown has all but admitted that their behaviour was illegal.

Their incompetence is breathtaking.

Their General Secretary and Charlie Gordon’s resignation are such small and unusual step these days.

We look forward to further developments, especially inside and outside both Parliaments.

The pantomimes continue.

Let Democracy Rule.

"ITS TIME" for Labour to come clean.

If not then let Wendy continue to be the best wee recruiting sergeant for the SNP that they've ever had.

When will ir all end ?.

.
Posted by: Tom McAlister on 1:11am Sun 9 Dec 07
... and have you seen the Sunday Times article entitled; Muslims lobby group hid identity of Labour donor.

Now who is this Salwar chappie ? Indeed, more revelations from the heart of bandit country.

All the little bits of the jigsaw are slowly but surely being dragged, kicking and screaming innocence and good faith into the big picture.

So what will a future meja headline be entitled, eh. Labour's dirty laundry exposed or could it be Labour's dirty money laundering exposed?


Posted by: iain morrison, nairn on 1:14am Sun 9 Dec 07
On the specific point about using Holyrood facilities for fundraising purposes, Jackie Baillie said: "If any of those who were helping out on the campaign has committed a minor breach in this way, then we are sincerely sorry."

Aye sorry you were caught - superb reporting keep it up.

Posted by: doonhamer on 1:15am Sun 9 Dec 07
What a deceitful bunch. The Labour Parody is just an embarrasment to Scotland. Every offense is just a wee mistake, never intential, just a bit of fuss to be brushed over.

The next opinion poll may not even have Labour in double digits as even the core of the party is disgusted by the never ending revelations of corruption and greed.
Posted by: ditchgazza on 1:32am Sun 9 Dec 07
Shhh. Listen.
Did you hear that?

Sounds like the liebour gravy train grinding to a halt.
Posted by: Bad Yin, In Struggle on 1:37am Sun 9 Dec 07
Paul Hutcheon, Scottish Political Editor,

well done laddie!

Wee Wendy must think it's halloween 'cause there's skeletons in the closet, and monsters behind every door. Aye - it's really scary oot there Wendy when ye don't know who tae trust.

As fur the rest of us - it's a wee bit less scary 'cause we know who not to trust - you!
Posted by: Who gives a....., Glasgow on 1:39am Sun 9 Dec 07
Last week I Voted that Wendy should resign.... I would very much like to change that. Wendy must stay... there are so many reasons why she must stay, quitting is just too easy. Take the hard road, go for the moral high ground, make the press work for their readership, give them more to do in the investigative journalism department. Aye, I think Eck is right, she’s doing a grand job as Scottish Labour leader !!!
Posted by: Harry, Scotland on 1:41am Sun 9 Dec 07
The SNP press team worked out of the parliament full time prior to the election. press releases sent out on scottish parliament emails, parliament phone numbers given as contact. did we hear a peep about it? No. double standards me thinks
Posted by: karin on 1:41am Sun 9 Dec 07
tom at 1.11
That would be mohammed sarwar you meant. Would this be the same mohammed sarwar whos son was convicted of money laundering. Mohammed sarwar is i beleive a friend of imran khand a gentleman who runs a computer firm and also allegedly has connections to an arms dealer in pakistan.
Posted by: DJ, Glasgow on 1:45am Sun 9 Dec 07
Why did Wendy get 6 days to submit the relevant documents to the Electoral Commision? Have the Electoral Commision never heard of shredders? I hope their IT department are better then me, but suspect they might not be.
Posted by: baffies away on 1:48am Sun 9 Dec 07
harry - your a little confused, the complaint is not that it was about a party office being used during a national election but that this was an internal Labour party election.
Posted by: DJ, Glasgow on 2:01am Sun 9 Dec 07
And all legal. Not just £950. There is no pattern to deceive, no intention to hide, oh, here is a £500k legal donation within the rules!
Posted by: Alex Brodie, Edinburgh on 2:04am Sun 9 Dec 07
The price Labour is paying to keep Wendy Alexander in her job is starting to look ruinous for Labour in Scotland and potentially catastophic for Labour overall. Let's hope she survives as leader of Labour's MSPs - she's a complete liability.
Posted by: Brian Blessed, Glasgow on 2:23am Sun 9 Dec 07
Karin @ 1:41

You mean the same Mohammed Sarwar whose son is now candidate for the Glasgow Central Westminster seat? Whilst the other son does time for VAT fraud? Whose former election agent, Margaret Curran, is W. Alexander's right hand wummin? Whose business associate Maq Rasul diddled hundreds of employees out of months of wages when his dodgy house of cards collasped, with Global DVD Ltd going bust?

Yes, the "peoples' party" are certainly one helluva lot of chancers. Shame no-one noticed till now.
Posted by: Tired of excuses, Galashiels on 3:03am Sun 9 Dec 07
Oh dear , how is labour ever going to explain this little lot away ?

Saint Jackie Bailie also starting to catch fallout, should be interesting to see who Wendy gets to make excuses for her next.
Posted by: Andy McArthur, Paris (back to Edinburgh tmrw) on 3:14am Sun 9 Dec 07
Imagine - Wendy Alexander is famous abroad! Something no other Scot Labour Party leader has achieved (even the comic act known as Jack McConnell). Unfortunately she's famous because she's seen as an easily-bought, low-influence, low-rent nitwit. Why is she so cheap if she their leader?
Posted by: Scunnert, Free at Last - Free at Last - Thank God All Mighty - Free at Last! on 3:20am Sun 9 Dec 07
Had this post at Scotland on Sunday deleted:

Bad Yin, Off to Read a Real Newspaper

WENDY HIT BY NEW REVELATIONS
* Secret donor list was sent from Alexander's office
* Holyrood rules broken by using MSP facilities for Party fundraising
* Third inquiry to be launched, this time by Parliamentary Standards Committee
The trail that goes to the heart of Holyrood
By Paul Hutcheon, Scottish Political Editor

I'm moderated there for posting similar under "scunnert".

Thank god for the Herald (on any day of the week).
Posted by: karim gazioglu, Gateshead, North of Englanf on 3:22am Sun 9 Dec 07
Wow! Labour are scary. I'm almost old enough to remember when they had decent people in them. Like my parents. I saw a Tory on tv last night called Hazel Blears, claiming to be labour. Who'd believe that!!
Posted by: martin, dundee on 4:02am Sun 9 Dec 07
London Labour in meltdown.It is hard to see how Alexander can stay as leader now but no doubt she will just brush this aside by saying ''using my own office was wrong but not intentional''.
The MSPs who supported her last week must realise she is now a serious liability.
Posted by: somerferg, OZ on 4:23am Sun 9 Dec 07

Ah Wendygate just refuses to go away despite the best efforts of the usual unionist press hawf-wits. Can't even begin to tell you how much fun it is to see the NUmpty labourites skwirming around like weasels in a poke.
Posted by: The Wild Linoleum Boy, Fife on 5:58am Sun 9 Dec 07
Since Charlie Gordon accepted an illegal personal donation from Paul Green to help fund his successful bid to become MSP for Cathcart and now he has admitted accepting this illegal donation for Wendy's "leadership" coronation, any criminal investigation that follows, must examine Gordon's bank account details between 2000-06 when as leader of Glasgow City Council Gordon had dealt with Green personally over the matter of planning permission for the £450m shopping centre. It is a scary thought that the graft, bribery, pay-offs and corruption involving various councillors and councils throughout the 60's and 70's in particular is still alive and well and thriving.
Posted by: A cabal/mob that is in meltdown and is melting Brown on 6:06am Sun 9 Dec 07
The King of the village half-wits would see the reality whole episode.

The Labour Party in ENGLAND/Westminster and Gordon Brown in particlular will be hammered because of this seedy behaviour at Holyrood.

Brown will be deemed as pert of this "Scottish" cabal. It will be easy for the Tories to project that image. Decent Labour voters down there will not vote for such a clique. They won't.

Power Suit Wendy is bringing Labour down more generally. The Labour mob at Holyrood are foolish in a way I find incredible. Why do they not see what I say?

In Scotland the Party is in meltdown - they look like a seedy cabal/mob. They look like opportunists with their noses in the trough.

Who will ever trust Donald's poodle again.

It will surely take more than phony wee "girly looks" and wiggling of the bum to save the Labour mob.
Posted by: Paul, Wendy (Big) House on 6:12am Sun 9 Dec 07
Have Labour received any legal donations?

I think we must be told!

One starts to get the feeling that if they lost the toss of a coin they'd look for an illegal get-out!
Posted by: She MUST be charged - do the POLICEMEN and WOMEN want a decent political system? on 6:36am Sun 9 Dec 07


WHY would anyone give money to the Labour Party now? If they do people will ask why? They will look like crooks by giving them it.

As for Wendy, SHE is the person legally responsible for the donation.

Wendy, stop trying to hide behind others. You look very seedy doing that. Oh, I see one of you "comrades" in your constituency party has been done with fraud. I wonder who will be next? Knock KNOCK. The people of Scotland deserve better than them - they really do. Knock KNOCK KNOCK
Posted by: Her constituency party on 6:37am Sun 9 Dec 07
The police must also focus on her constituency party.
Posted by: Yeti on 6:54am Sun 9 Dec 07
To plagiarise Monty Python: "Hold on Theathar, I may be of thum athithtanth"
Posted by: Buddy on 7:13am Sun 9 Dec 07
A degree of candour is required of the Labour Party in Scotland. Wendy Alexander, its leader, has been pushed to the edge of resignation because she accepted £950 from Paul Green, a Jersey-based businessman, who was plainly not allowed to contribute to her campaign when she stood (ultimately unopposed) for her position.

She has survived partly because Charlie Gordon, a fellow MSP, has admitted that it was he who solicited this support, partly because it is uncertain whether Ms Alexander or her campaign Treasurer were legally responsible for the errant cheque, and also because she insists that e-mails show that she pressed her colleagues to check if Mr Green's donation was permissible.

Ms Alexander would do well to place such evidence in the public domain, irrespective of the constabulary's abiding interest in the case.
Posted by: Disgusted Dorothy, Glasgow on 7:30am Sun 9 Dec 07
Well done,Mr Hutcheon!
Keep up the good work!
It is a pleasure to have a journalist of your calibre working for the benefit of the Scottish people and not for the benefit of a party!
Posted by: Astonished, Inverclyde on 8:23am Sun 9 Dec 07
Firstly very well done to the Sunday Herald. My sincere thanks - it is a pity I can only get the unvarnished truth once a week.

Alexander, Gordon, McCabe, Whitton, McNeil and Baillie must all resign from the Scottish parliament. Some for corruption and the remaining two for defending corruption.

The Electoral commission should lose a few people and the Scottish Chief Constables are looking more and more dodgy. An unbiased investigation into their dealings and connections with the numpty party is now necessary.
Posted by: CJM, west lothian on 8:35am Sun 9 Dec 07
Is there a SNP sleeper labour party ? Alex seems to be extremly well informed or is the labour not only currupt but incompitent.
Team Alexander must now step down they cant hope to spin this no matter how many spin doctors they send up from London.
Posted by: CJM, west lothian on 8:37am Sun 9 Dec 07
Is there a SNP sleeper labour party ? Alex seems to be extremly well informed or is the labour not only currupt but incompitent.
Team Alexander must now step down they cant hope to spin this no matter how many spin doctors they send up from London.
Posted by: steve4349, larbet on 8:43am Sun 9 Dec 07
labour have no respect for the law of the land,the rules of hollyrood,they give the impression they would steal the sugar out of your tea,but wendy woo the polis will come for you.
Posted by: BM, Glasgow on 8:56am Sun 9 Dec 07
Andy McArthur wrote:
Imagine - Wendy Alexander is famous abroad! Something no other Scot Labour Party leader has achieved (even the comic act known as Jack McConnell). Unfortunately she\'s famous because she\'s seen as an easily-bought, low-influence, low-rent nitwit. Why is she so cheap if she their leader?
Not entirely true - Wee Jack was famous abroad for making an eejit of himself in New York, appearing in public a pin striped skirt.
Posted by: Astonished, Inverclyde on 8:59am Sun 9 Dec 07
It gets worse -
http://news.independ
ent.co.uk/uk/politic
s/article3236134.ece


Hopefully that's the numpties finished here - lets get on with taking Scotland forward !
Posted by: GAT, glasgow on 9:01am Sun 9 Dec 07
...team Alexander was guilty of "gross mismanagement" seemed to complement a weekend of shocking headlines. But hours later, Alexander read out a well-received statement to the media at Holyrood and took questions from the press.


This is the key to Wendy's future. Her powerful friends in the media, not the Labour Party or MSPs, will decide this matter. Wendy is part of the elite who know what's best for Scotland and they are not ready to let her go.
Posted by: Bounty, Musselburgh on 9:03am Sun 9 Dec 07
I'd check the validity of their Microsoft licenses as well while we are at it.
Posted by: An t-Amadan, Alba on 9:08am Sun 9 Dec 07
Douglas Alexander has been caught trying to rig an election - one of the most serious crimes a politician could be guilty of. His sister is caught up to the neck in corruption, lies and perverting the course of justice. What hold do this obnoxious family have over Gordon Brown? What have they caught him against and what blackmail evidence do they have of him? What makes the pair of them above the law and apparently invulnerable?
They are touted as "intellectuals" but are in relaity as thick as mince. If someone is a real intellectual there is no point in having to hammer home the point as has been happening.
If Brown does not get them booted out of the party and investigated by the police, they will destroy him and has party - permanently. The Labour party will be no more, with the biggest party of all being that celebrating its demise.
Posted by: Curley Bill, the southwest on 9:10am Sun 9 Dec 07
Once upon a time there was a real Labour Party in Scotland. They were a group of firebrands dedicated to pulling the working class out of squalor, to improving the wages, health and living conditions of the common people. They believed in Home Rule for Scotland (they railed against the Great War - "Why fight for one German King against another German King").
In short, they were everything the desperadoes who've stolen their name aren't.
Scotland needs independence, and it also needs a Real Labour Party.
Maybe, after the great day, all like-minded true socialists could get together and reclaim their heritage - and all of the present wasters could fade, unlamented, into oblivion.
Posted by: Curley Bill, the southwest on 9:14am Sun 9 Dec 07
By the way - at the next Journalist of the Year awards, it will be a travesty if Mr Hutcheon isn't the winner.
Posted by: BM, Glasgow on 9:18am Sun 9 Dec 07
Astonished wrote:
It gets worse -
http://news.independ
ent.co.uk/uk/politic
s/article3236134.ece


Hopefully that's the numpties finished here - lets get on with taking Scotland forward !
That's interesting. The Highways Agency opposed Abrahams' development, but changed its mind a month after a massive donation by him to the Labour Party. The Highways agency is part of the Ministry of Transport run by - guess who - Douglas Alexander!!! The Alexander name keeps popping up with monotonous regularity in all these scandals!
Posted by: Mac, Dundee on 9:19am Sun 9 Dec 07
More evidence that Wendy Alexander and her campaign team delibrately set out to conceal and deceive. More evidence too that her defence constructed around 'ignorance of the law' is part of a cover-up, one organised by Downing Street.

It begs again the obvious questions;

Why are the Electoral Commission dragging it's heels?

Why are the police not involved?

Why are the Scottish media protecting the guilty?

If this involved a Mr. A Salmond and an illegal 1p donation we know the said person would be in jail, publicly disgraced and villified by the press.

This whole affair is a national scandal, one that demeans public life in Scotland.
Posted by: Duns Scotus, The Borders on 9:53am Sun 9 Dec 07
So the Dumbarton Rock brain is the rock on which the rotten hull of the pirate ship NuLabour will perish.

Meanwhile the crew are running around like headless chickens, stashing dubloons in their pockets (well the NHS ones and Charlie Gordon are)while others wield cutlasses at their mates backs instead of falling on them.

They're in the soup - P.Green soup!
Posted by: BM, Glasgow on 10:00am Sun 9 Dec 07
From today's Sunday Torygraph

"The Sunday Telegraph has also learnt that the police inquiry launched last week will examine a decision by Douglas Alexander, then the secretary of state for transport, to approve a new £11.4 million road close to Mr Abrahams's development. The decision was made soon after Mr Abrahams's proxy donations were made in 2005.

The 2.5-mile road would greatly improve access to Mr Abrahams's site.

Carol Woods, the deputy leader of Durham City Council, has referred the matter to the police. "Plans for this road had been around a long time but hadn't been going anywhere because the money for it hadn't been around. Then all of a sudden, when Mr Abrahams is giving money to the Labour Party and trying to develop a business park, it is revived and approved by the Government," she said."
Posted by: Duns Scotus, The Borders on 10:06am Sun 9 Dec 07
From The Independent (thanks Astonished for the link)

Planners fast-tracked Labour donor's business park scheme
Industrial development passed for planning one month after David Abrahams gave Labour almost £100,000
By Brian Brady, Whitehall Editor
Published: 09 December 2007

David Abrahams was put on a fast-track planning scheme for his multimillion-pound industrial park only a month after he used three "proxies" to hand the Labour Party donations totalling almost £100,000.
The controversial Labour donor gave over £99,000 to Labour just before Christmas 2005, exactly a month before his multimillion-pound Durham Green proposal was one of only 21 projects nationwide included in a pilot scheme designed to "improve and speed up the planning process for large and complex developments".

Douglas Alexander is deep doo-doo.

Labour official blamed for secret donations will fight to clear name
By Andrew Grice, Political Editor
Published: 07 December 2007

Peter Watt, who resigned as Labour's general secretary over the party's secret donations, is to come out fighting in an attempt to clear his name.
Mr Watt has told friends that he is not prepared to be the scapegoat for the £600,000 in donations from the property developer David Abrahams through four intermediaries.
His determination to fight back will worry Gordon Brown, who hoped that his resignation last week would help to draw a line under the controversy. Allies of Mr Watt are furious that the Prime Minister admitted the law had been broken the day after he quit, which they believe made a police investigation inevitable. Scotland Yard announced an inquiry two days after Mr Brown's remarks.

Mr Watt will no doubt be on the phone to Charlie Gordon.
Posted by: Slime Searcher, oot and aboot on 10:10am Sun 9 Dec 07
and of course the Deputy Leader of the Labour Group on Edinburgh's Council has also been up to dodgy dealings for years ....

http://edinburghnews

.scotsman.com/index.

cfm?id=1911252007

It just gets better.
Posted by: richard, West Lothian on 10:10am Sun 9 Dec 07
"English fear for future of Union"

Check out this headline from the "Torygraph" in the Breaking News section of the paper.
Posted by: richard, West Lothian on 10:12am Sun 9 Dec 07
"English fear for future of Union"

Check out this headline from the "Torygraph" in the Breaking News section of the paper.
Posted by: will on 10:15am Sun 9 Dec 07
Brian Blessed at 2.04

Yes you are right to list the connections between Mohammed Sarwar, his jailed son, the bankrupt video tycoon, and Ms Alexanders right hand assistant.

However, I seem to recall also that it may have been one Mohammed Sarwar who was caught handing over a brown paper bag with I thousands of pounds to a political opponent during a general election.

As I also recall that after due investigation it was concluded that no crime was committed - it was just one of these things that you do when you are a Labour candidate.

Yes, his son will make a good Labour candidate, the family will have trained him well and he will be standing for the right party.
Posted by: John J, Edinburgh on 10:21am Sun 9 Dec 07
The Wendy Alexander Fund For Leadership Election was set up so that she did not personally receive any donations and therefor does not have to declare them in her list of members interests at the Scottish Parliament.
WAFFLE then came under the auspices of the Labour Party and the law is that if donations are less than £1,000 the donor's name does not have to be published.
All perfectly legal and demonstrating how clever is our Wendy.
Why does she have to go to such lengths to hide the names of doners ?
Posted by: Melanthios on 10:25am Sun 9 Dec 07
¨¨¨oooOOOOOOOOOOO
¨¨¨[]_______________
_________
¨¨/......|[]...[]… []...[]...[]...[]...
[]...[]|||__________
_______
¨/___|_____|-|______
___________|;|_GRAVY
_TRAIN_|;
/oo--OO---oo---oo---
oo---oo---oo- --oo-------oo-------
-oo
+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-
+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-
+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+
Posted by: Melanthios on 10:25am Sun 9 Dec 07
Ho hum...that didn't work. Oh well.
Posted by: TheWiseOne, Glasgow on 10:31am Sun 9 Dec 07
Henry McLeish must be having a good laugh at all this. At least he resigned when he got into the mire.

Wonder if Sam Galbraith will want to retract his comments about Wee Wendy.

If Labour are really trying to play this episode out, they must put a gag on Jackie Baillie's gob. Make that a blanket as it is a rather big gob.

Does anyone else think the mole is a Jack McConnell supporter who is unhappy at the way he was dumped from office?

Posted by: Melanthios on 10:34am Sun 9 Dec 07
One more try then I'm off.


¨¨¨oooOOOOOOOOOOO
¨¨¨[]_______________
________
¨¨/......|[]...[]… ..[]...[]|
¨/___|_____|-|__GRAV
Y_TRAIN__|
/oo--OO---oo---oo---
oo---oo-;
+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-
+-+-+-+-++-+-+-+-+
Posted by: Melanthios on 10:35am Sun 9 Dec 07
Erse!
Posted by: TMcL on 10:45am Sun 9 Dec 07
Melanthios wrote:
One more try then I'm off.


¨¨¨oooOOOOOOOOOOO
¨¨¨[]_______________
________
¨¨/......|[]...[]… ..[]...[]|
¨/___|_____|-|__GRAV
Y_TRAIN__|
/oo--OO---oo---oo---
oo---oo-;
+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-
+-+-+-+-++-+-+-+-+
On the Chattanooga Choo-choo?
Posted by: TheWiseOne, Glasgow on 10:48am Sun 9 Dec 07
Melanthios wrote:
¨¨¨oooOOOOOOOOOOO ¨¨¨[]_______________ _________ ¨¨/......|[]...[]… []...[]...[]...[]... []...[]|||__________ _______ ¨/___|_____|-|______ ___________|;|_GRAVY _TRAIN_|; /oo--OO---oo---oo--- oo---oo---oo- --oo-------oo------- -oo +-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+- +-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+- +-+-+-+-+-+-+-+
Is this some secret code for collecting donations?
Posted by: Wullie on 10:53am Sun 9 Dec 07
Just to change the subject -

They have learnt that the Scots, who already enjoy free personal care, are now to benefit from free university tuition and free prescriptions too - all paid for by English taxes. Yet Scotland's nationalist First Minister, Alex Salmond, has the temerity to complain he is getting too little money from Westminster .

Today's John Bull headline from the Sunday Telegraph, which incidentally is launching a campaign to support Britishness?

Feel British do we ?
Posted by: david, london on 11:03am Sun 9 Dec 07
Douglas Alexander is the Labour election supremo and his sister was standing for election. Why is no one asking what Douglas Alexander knew about his sister's election campaign back in August. Did he see the dodgy document, did he approve the dodgy donation. Would she really run an election campaign without help or advice from the Labour election supremo. Since GB wanted her to win who would keep him informed. Who meets him every day. Is Douglas Alexander the missing link. Alexander Balls and Brown all meet every day. Cooper Ball's wife department fast tracked the Abrahams application.
This needs a lot of investigation, Watergate started as a breakin and ended as a breakout of the most important leader in the world. This is an iceberg there is a lot more beneath the surface.
Posted by: Colin B, BEArsden on 11:16am Sun 9 Dec 07
How long can Wendy hang on a lawbreaker leader among lawmakers? The answer is as long as a corrupt and biased Electoral Commission, POlice Force and Crown Office allows her to, as the Labour party will just go into denial.
Posted by: TheWiseOne, Glasgow on 11:23am Sun 9 Dec 07
It is pretty obvious that Labour are going to ride this one out, secure in the knowledge that another disastrous event will soon take precedence. Then it will be history, pretty much like Labour in Scotland
Posted by: Sarky and Sparky, Glasgow on 11:31am Sun 9 Dec 07
Wendy wears the Trousers
(Tune of “Donald where’s your trousers?”)

I just rolled in, to catch a spy,
I’m no very big, but I’m unco fly,
And I’ll ferret out, who did dare defy,
Me - “Wendy wears the Trousers”.

I’m most concerned, about this leak,
I’ll let them know, who wears the breeks,
And to the press, they’ll no more speak,
‘Cos I’m “Wendy wears the Trousers”!

When I find who it was, I will crucify,
Hang them out, on a line to dry,
“Veritas” – is no defence, in my eyes!
Not to “Wendy wears the Trousers”.

Just let them, “public interest” wail,
My Lorded friends, will seek the jail,
For these whistle-blowers, and I’ll prevail.
Long may “Wendy wear the Trousers”!

Posted by: BM, Glasgow on 11:33am Sun 9 Dec 07
When I was a boy in Lanarkshire the Labour Party were totally and openly corrupt. You got the best council houses if you were a relative of a councillor. Many of the Lanarkshire MPs were closely related. All their families went into teaching and got very fast promotion to headmastership's, in spite of total lack of ability. On appointment to Provost, councillors stopped working and bought business and pubs with suddenly and mysteriously acquired funds. Corruption and nepotism were rife. Labour politicians were hated by the people and despised for their corruption, but they skilfully played the Tory bogeymen card to keep the people voting for them.
For a while it seemed that their act had been cleaned up, but now it seems the corruption was just hidden beneath the surface. However now the bogeyman does not exist - their is a party who did starve their grandfathers or great grandfathers into submission during the miners' strike of the 1920s, so the corrupt Labour stranglehold on Scottish politics is being broken, and we are beginning to see the results.
Posted by: greig, glasgow on 11:36am Sun 9 Dec 07
THE SUNDAY MAIL,REPORTS NOTHING AGAIN.WHY NOT?
ARE YOU ON THE PAYROLL TOO!MAY BE THE RECORD WILL COME CLEAN TOMORROW(JOKE).WHEN WILL YOU PEOPLE LEARN TO REPORT THE REAL BIG ISSUES AND NOT TO BURY YOUR HEADS IN THE PALE.SCOTLAND DESERVES BETTER.
Posted by: Jason, Borders on 11:38am Sun 9 Dec 07
And the revelation this week is??????

What a disappointing story. At least last weeks story had substance but this weeks shock horror that an e mail address (which presumably you can access from any PC with remote access) was used to e mail a document at a cost to the taxpapyer of maybe 0.00000001 p is a damp squib and suggests Hutcheons hasn't found anything new. Good job he wasn't given the Waterhate story at the time eh! Seems to me this is going to die a death....
Posted by: bamba, edinburgh on 11:59am Sun 9 Dec 07
Wendy (didnae kenn) Alexander, having aparently got herself back to the doll's house this last week, finds to her horror that she has actually ended up in the doghouse again! The facts revealed by your reporter's doggedness to search for the bones of truth, now reveal a dog's dinner of connivance involving donations to the Labour Party in Scotland which can be directly linked to Wendy's own Parliamentary office. This rather begs the following questions:
Why someone who has a reputation for having a stranglehold on everything that is going on around her, can deny that she know nothing about the donors? As the list came from her office, one can assume there were other directions such as who was to solicit the donations from whom?
Who made the decision to elicit from so many donors to donate sums just under the notification threshold of £1000?
If we are to believe Mr. Green - and we have no reason at present to doubt him - that he only gave two donations to the Labour Party in Scotland which amounted to less than two thousand pounds, then what earthly reason had five senior Labour figures in Scotland to sign nomination papers for him to be awarded an honour? I am sure the 4 individuals south of the border who were involved in the cash for peerages row at Westminster must feel agrieved at the fire sale price here in Alba.
Mr. Green has, to the knowledge of the general public, done absolutely nothing in Scotland to warrant any honour, simply made a lot of money in deals involving property development and the glasgow Council. Don't you think that the individuals within the Labour Party in Scotland who signed those nomination papers owe us an explanation as to why Mr. Green and the four other donors like him, were nominated?
The Scottish Labour Party have to answer these and many other questions, as well as take the consequences of their arrogant belief that they are above the law, before the donation and nomination stories will go away.
Posted by: Rod, Glasgow on 12:17pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Re Jason 1138
I think you're clutching at straws!!
The point regarding the e-mail is not the cost but the fact that Wendy's team had a secret list which she did not see. Do these people in her team never talk to each other?
Posted by: wullie on 12:19pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Labour was paid £180,000 from public funds to help party officials to understand new funding rules shortly before it began accepting secret donations from a property developer, The Times can reveal.

The party applied for and received a “start-up grant” from the Electoral Commission to meet the costs of abiding by the law on declaring donations that Labour had itself enacted. It was for training staff in the duties imposed by the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000 and was specifically for the party to prepare for its requirements on submitting accounts and declaring donations
above £5,000.


It gets worse by the day. A fifth of a million pounds of taxpayers money given to New Labour to train the party in the requirements of Electoral Law.

This is fraud - the claiming of money under false pretences - and the taxpayer should have the money repaid, with penalties.

Systematic, systemic and willfull corruption.

The Mafia look like amateurs by comparison to New Labour.
Posted by: Tom McAlister on 12:23pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Jason, Borders.wrote:

Seems to me this is going to die a death...
____________________
____________________
_______

You appeared unable to finish the sentence, Jason.

Allow me.

Seems to me this is going to die a death.... of a thousand cuts.

.

Posted by: cadgers, Perth on 12:24pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Jason wrote:
And the revelation this week is??????

What a disappointing story. At least last weeks story had substance but this weeks shock horror that an e mail address (which presumably you can access from any PC with remote access) was used to e mail a document at a cost to the taxpapyer of maybe 0.00000001 p is a damp squib and suggests Hutcheons hasn't found anything new. Good job he wasn't given the Waterhate story at the time eh! Seems to me this is going to die a death....
In yer dreams Jason, where are your argonauts? 'Cause this juggernaut will take a lot of stopping.
quote
Posted by: jim mitchell, Sauchie, Clack's on 12:31pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Jason, borders, yes that'll be right Jason, labour break the rules but it doesn't matter, why doesn't it matter,because it's labour, so lets just forget about it.

One set of rules for them.........
Posted by: Duns Scotus, The Borders on 12:31pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Jason, is your favourite song "I'm dreaming of a whitewash Christmas"?
Posted by: John J. Sheridan, Z'ha'dum on 12:32pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Why has AM2 nothing to say on this subject?
He can't keep his gob shut on every other thread and forum.
Posted by: jim mitchell, Sauchie, clack's on 12:38pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Wullie, I was thinking along the same lines, either Labour have to admit that as a party their too thick to have learnt the rules, despite all the money, or there will be the suggestion that they obtained the money under false pretences, so someone should be looking into how and where this money or any part of it spent so far has went.

There is another issue here though, it is high time the ordinary rank and file members of labour were speaking out about these things, do they support their leaders or not and why?

There are also those MSP's who gave Wendy thir full backing, what's their opinion now?

And where's Lord foulkes when you need a quote?
Posted by: bamba, edinburgh on 12:49pm Sun 9 Dec 07
So, when Wendy is in trouble and wishes to hide behind the guise of no comment, out comes her mate, Jaqui Baillie. I have a problem with Wendy's argument of not commenting on a matter which is being investigated, then allowing Mz Baillie to appear throughout the media to defend Mz Alexander. Was not Jaquie part of the very team running the campaign which has raised the attention and interest of such parties as the Election Commission, the police and the Parliamentary Standards overseer?
I thought dear old Wendy was one of the intellectual giants of the Scottish Labour party but, chosing Jaquie Baillie as your chief defensive supporter, shows pygmy status within the intellectual stakes. Mz Baillie proved to be a fairly mediocre Minister when in office and is now reduced to being a bit of a rent-a-gub for the media, much in the mould of Lord brown-tongue of Cumnock/Loudon and the future Lord Haw Haw of Falkirk, both of whom served their master Blair with Micawberish unquestioning grovelling. Sadly, Mz Baillie is just one of too many within the Scottish Parliament who would make rather insignificant members of a local council.
Posted by: Tired of excuses, Galashiels on 12:49pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Only thing I can see dying a death here is the Labour parties' credibility.

It really does not matter if anyone resigns over this or not, staying in place like Wendy and Gordon are trying only damages the party further.

Neither of them have had the guts to appear on TV since any of this broke.

Maybe Jackie Baillie will finally shut up too now.

Posted by: HAMISH, ARGYLL on 12:51pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Abrahams Haughey etc. etc.etc.
Headlines
"ERMINE TRIMMER IN RECEIVERSHIP"
Never known such a slump in business. The trend had been upwards for some time.Future looks bleak.Says spokesman L.G.Foulkes for F.N.FOX + CO, Furriers to H.M.GOVT since 1997
Posted by: Aurora, Edinburgh on 12:53pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Wouldnt it be fascinating if "SNP Researcher"/Herald team were to have a look at the items emanating from the two Fish's offices !
Posted by: Big Stu on 12:55pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Sarky and Sparky, Glasgow on 11:31am today

Brilliant- LOL
Posted by: Aurora, Edinburgh on 1:02pm Sun 9 Dec 07
Colin B wrote:
How long can Wendy hang on a lawbreaker leader among lawmakers? The answer is as long as a corrupt and biased Electoral Commission, POlice Force and Crown Office allows her to, as the Labour party will just go into denial.
Talk about "aw oot a step but oor Jock" - obviously motto for the Nats these days when not claiming Labour policies as their own and the Big Fish smirking that he won the Commonwealth Games for Scotland when all the work was down to a Committee, jointly introduced by Jack McConnell and Glasgow's Labour Leader, Steven Purcell.

When will voters wake up and see howe much they are being conned by a Party that spent much more than the others in May, thanks to massive dosh from tax exiles and "suitors" for franchises presently in the gift of Wee Eck and Co ?
Posted by: Marian Shepherd, Baillieston, Glasgow on 1:07pm Sun 9 Dec 07
How on earth did these crooks manage to hijack something as big as the Labour Party? What a disgusting shower.
Posted by: Sarky and Sparky, Glasgow on 1:25pm Sun 9 Dec 07