Home
July 20, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
Arts minister blames ‘cautious’ predecessors for lack of creativity
Fabiani declares previous culture bill ‘effectively dead’

IT'S BEEN a busy eight months for Linda Fabiani since taking on the role of culture minister. She has condemned the "sticking plaster" approach to arts in the draft culture bill, hit back at critics of her policy towards the Scots language and desire to reclaim the Lewis Chessmen, and she has outlined her vision for Creative Scotland.

Since coming into office, Fabiani has made kindly noises towards the arts community - a sector terrified by the prospect of government interference. The draft culture bill, drawn up by the previous administration, proposed that ministers could give Creative Scotland "directions" that must be complied.

This part of the bill, in fact most of it according to Fabiani, is effectively dead. When it comes before parliament in the spring, the draft will be used to enact legislation to allow for the formation of Creative Scotland, and the merging of the Scottish Arts Council and Scottish Screen.

"Let's not diminish Creative Scotland by lumping it in with so many other things," Fabiani said, in a wide-ranging interview with the Sunday Herald.

The draft culture bill received the same reception from Fabiani as it did from the hundreds of artists and cultural bodies that registered concerns with the government. Fabiani called it "legislation for legislation's sake".

She took particular issue with "cultural entitlement", the vaguely-defined buzz phrase of the previous administration concerning widening access to the arts and culture - an initiative Fabiani said was put in place to "tick the boxes".

"I could not for the life of me see how this could energise because everybody's going to be running around saying, Let's do something to make sure everyone's had their cultural entitlement', she said. "I know that's a bit of a parody, but that's how it seemed to me."

She added: "When I was in opposition I used to say, how many initiatives can you have? Can we not just address the core and do something. And since I came into this post I've found a lot of sticking plasters."

She refers to this streamlining of the culture bill and pruning of initiatives as "clearing the landscape", which she rates as one of her main achievements in office so far.

And although she might have a disdain for initiatives, the culture minister has started one herself: an audit of the Scots language to see how many people speak it and where. It aims to explore ways the government can help promote and preserve the language of Burns. It's an initiative Fabiani takes personally.

"I'm quite proud of that," she said. "Some people are saying that she wants to fund slang'. Where are these people getting off saying Burns wrote slang?"

One high-profile cultural pledge has fallen off the radar since the SNP came to power. Prior to the party's victory last May, its cultural manifesto held the eye-catching promise to introduce a grant enabling artists to reclaim the cost of tax paid on work they sold up to a maximum of £15,000. Fabiani said the pledge is still on the agenda.

"The Irish model of tax breaks for artists is very interesting, but Westminster won't give us the powers in tax to allow us to do that, so that's something for the future. But we're absolutely determined artists should be supported in some way. We're currently looking to see how we can bring in a system of equivalence so we can get that going."

Fabiani said she ultimately wants to "invoke a resurgence of creativity". For this to happen, there needs to be "some out-of-the-box thinking and imaginative solutions."

So why hasn't this already been happening? Previous occupants of her role being "maybe a bit too cautious, certainly too prescriptive" has not helped, Fabiani said. Neither has the structure of important organisations.

Fabiani believes creative industries will only achieve their potential if they are allowed to take risks.

"Without risk, art becomes bland. "You've got to let these things soar, take wings and go for it. And that's what I want Creative Scotland to do."

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: subrosa on 2:29am Sun 3 Feb 08
Good article, I hope Creative Scotland begin to produce some work now.
Posted by: Donald Anderson, glasgow on 6:23am Sun 3 Feb 08
"It wisnae us", says Labour Opposition
Posted by: Donald Anderson, glasgow on 6:23am Sun 3 Feb 08
"It wisnae us", says Labour Opposition
Posted by: Pat Roller on 6:59am Sun 3 Feb 08
Fabiani is yet another Arts minister without a clue. . Her bold new approach to Creative Scotland (dreadful, self-regarding name!) is no more than an unquestioning adoption of Labour's tired and unthought-through concept.

The whole of the Scottish film industry, such as it is, unanimously opposed Labour's daft idea of welding together the 2 organisations. Despite this Fabiani is blithely carrying on regardless, embracing some vague management concept which is animating this dodo idea. As an SNP member I am deeply unimpressed that the New Scotland look depressingly like the old one.
Posted by: claudero, Edinburgh on 2:45pm Sun 3 Feb 08
What is creative about the body or bodies trussed together under that preposterous name "Creative Scotland" for a mere funding body? Pompous buffoonery applying it, it should be the object of ridicule. Grants for being famous a speciality of the Louse. No doubt over the years serious and informed and discriminating people have done hard work for the body, but dressing it up ... Putting them into costume, aaaaaaaaaaaaaahtists my aaaaaaaaaaaaahs! Drop the name CREATIVE SCOTLAND for the aaaaaaahs council etcetera. And..
Let the Muse hurl the first rotten tomato!
Posted by: Terry Anderson, President, Scottish Artists Union, Glasgow on 3:06pm Fri 8 Feb 08
Following this interview, Linda Fabiani appeared on Radio Café through the week and took questions from a few callers.

The minister stated, ahead of the Creative Nation summit, that she believes "creatives should lead the way" within the new Creative Scotland body. This being the case, the I must ask why no visual artist has been appointed to their interim board?

With regard to her party's manifesto promise of a tax break for artists, the minister reiterated her aim to seek to "introduce some equivalence" to a tax break, and that a conclusion would be forthcoming "in the next few months." The SAU will hold her to this promise; if no statement is made in time for the first anniversary of the SNP's election victory, we'll want to know why.

Finally, the minister said that the Scottish Government "do not see things in silos" and made a connection between participation in the arts and "well being". The SAU does not refute such a connection, but warns against the use of artists' labour as a social panacea. This echoes the "cultural entitlements" proposed in the 2006 Draft Culture (Scotland) Bill, described above as an initiative put in place to "tick the boxes."

This piece concludes with her contention that "without risk, art becomes bland." An embracement of risk chimes with the SAU's own 2007 election manifesto, and we therefore hope that she will preside over the formation of a new cultural agency that allows artists to thrive without being held to the commercial demands implied by the ubiquitous phrase "creative industries".
Add your comment
Name:
Email: *
Location:
**
Security Image. Registered site users are not required to enter Security Image Information.
 
 e.g. 123-123
Comment:
Please note: All HTML tags will be ignored.
Format Text:

 
By posting a comment, I confirm that I have read and agree to the terms of use. Comments are not moderated but we will react if anything that breaks the rules comes to our attention and we may delete inappropriate postings. Please treat other people with respect. You must not post anything that is abusive, indecent, unlawful or defamatory. Remember, you are personally liable for what you post on this site. If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us here.
* Your email address will not be displayed
** To avoid register now or login