Home
September 06, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
A prayer for a greener Scotland
Three main faiths unite to urge Holyrood to act against global warming
By Rob Edwards
Environment Editor

SCOTLAND'S THREE MAIN FAITHS have come together this weekend in an unprecedented plea to government ministers to raise the game on climate change. They have warned Scotland must toughen its plans to cut the pollution warming the globe to help prevent millions from dying in poor countries.

Protestant, Catholic and Islamic leaders are urging the Scottish National Party not to abandon its manifesto commitment to reduce climate pollution by 3% a year.

They have come out in support of demands made by Stop Climate Chaos Scotland - a new coalition of more than 30 groups with at least 1.5 million supporters. The coalition's campaign for more action to tackle climate change, also being launched today, is backed by the Sunday Herald.

"We must not turn a blind eye to the suffering of the most vulnerable people who will continue to be those most acutely affected by climate change," states a letter from faith leaders to the Cabinet finance secretary, John Swinney.

The letter was signed by the moderator of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland, the Right Reverend Sheilagh Kesting; Archbishop of St Andrews and Edinburgh, Cardinal Keith O'Brien; and the leading Scottish imam, Sheikh Muhammad Ruzwan.

"Our faiths tell us that human beings have a responsibility of stewardship over the earth, and a duty to look after the world's poorest citizens," they state. "We are gravely concerned by climate change and see an important role for the Scottish government and MSPs in tackling this urgent problem."

The Scottish government has published a draft bill to tackle climate change, which is out for public consultation until April 23. Although the faith leaders welcome the bill's promised 80% cut in climate pollution by 2050, they are concerned not all the commitments needed to meet that target are in place.

The consultation document on the bill appears to drop the SNP's 2007 manifesto promise of "mandatory carbon reduction targets of 3% per annum". Such targets, it says, would not create "a credible framework due to the large fluctuations in Scotland's emissions".

But according to the three faith leaders, the government's proposals "need to be strengthened if the bill is to live up to its intended aims". They point out that Swinney is in a unique position to ensure the Scottish climate change bill really does show international leadership.

They also explicitly endorse calls of the Stop Climate Chaos Scotland coalition, which include annual budgets to ensure cuts in climate pollution of at least 3% a year and inclusion of emissions from aviation and shipping.

The coalition also wants the bill "to have enshrined within it the principle of Scotland making an equitable contribution to global efforts to keep average temperature rises below two degrees centigrade". This is regarded by scientists as the level above which climate change could become dangerous and irreversible.

THE faith leaders want governments to take "strong and urgent action in line with the latest scientific consensus". The cost of failure will be counted in lives, they say, as well as in cash and environmental degradation.

"Around 150,000 people are already dying each year from diseases attributable to climate change. Without action to cut greenhouse gases and help for developing countries to adapt, suffering will only intensify," they argue.

"The current situation is deeply unjust given that developing countries in the south have done least to cause the problem and are least able to adapt to the effects of climate change."

The leaders promise to encourage their respective Scottish communities to lobby MSPs to support strengthening of the climate change bill. In their letter, which was sent last Thursday, they also request a meeting with Swinney.

They are backed by the three aid agencies they represent: Christian Aid, Scottish Catholic International Aid Fund and Islamic Relief. Along with environmental, development, community, student, trade union and women's groups, they have formed the Stop Climate Chaos Scotland coalition.

The Scottish government stressed it wanted to exceed a 3% per year reduction in emissions.

"We will have in place an annual measure of progress to monitor the practical steps that we take to achieve our objectives," said a government spokeswoman.

But she said this had to take account of Scotland's "volatile" emissions, which varied by up to 6% per year because of changing weather and fuel prices. Reporting annual progress "within a multi-year budget process" would be the best method, she argued.

She added: "We welcome the views of Scotland's faith leaders and would encourage as many people as possible to make their views known."

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: Margaret Lyons, Edinburgh on 11:06am Sun 30 Mar 08
Hmm - Scottish CO2 emissions went up by 14% for the last year that figures were available 2006-2005. The entire reason for this was the neglect of our nuclear power stations which meant that production from Scotlands coal and gas power plants went up by 35%.

And who has been Scotland's lead campaigner for the last 30 years against nuclear power? Step forward MR ROB EDWARDS - the Herald,s environment correspondent! Idiot.
Posted by: Rachel Young, Blairgowrie on 11:29am Thu 3 Apr 08
This is a fantastic news piece. Great to see the faiths coming together to tackle such an important issue. Hopefully the Government will pay attention to what they're saying, and stick with the 3% annual reductions. We are being presented with a real chance for Scotland to be a global leader in the area of climate change, let's not waste it.

Good to see Stop Climate Chaos getting some publicity too. There's more info about their members on the website www.stopclimatechaos


scotland.org
- everyone from SAMH to UNISON!.

Btw, Margaret, you're talking tosh. Don't bring nuclear into the climate change debate, because it really doesn't belong there. Whatever your thoughts are on nuclear in terms of safety and ethics, it certainly isn't the answer to climate change.

While the energy generation itself might not pump out CO2 into the atmosphere, the mining, extraction, processsing and transportation of uranium ore certainly does. As does the building and decommissioning of plants.

The Government's independent watchdog on sustainable development has said that even doubling our nuclear capacity will only lead to an 8% reduction in emissions, which is nowhere close to the 80% we need.

Add to that the obvious facts that uranium is a finite resource just like gas and coal, that nuclear power is nowhere near as economically attractive as the (heavily subsidised) industry, claims, and that it will take at least 15 years for a new nuclear plant to come online (by which time we will probably be too late to halt runaway climate change if we carry on business as usual)... and nuclear starts to look like the ridiculously wrong option it is.

That's before you even get into the issues of waste, or the horrendous conditions in uranium mines - the displacement of indigenous peoples, contamination of the environment, and increased cancer rates in mine workers.

There's certainly an idiot round here, but it's not Rob Edwards.

Add your comment
Name:
Email: *
Location:
**
Security Image. Registered site users are not required to enter Security Image Information.
 
 e.g. 123-123
Comment:
Please note: All HTML tags will be ignored.
Format Text:

 
By posting a comment, I confirm that I have read and agree to the terms of use. Comments are not moderated but we will react if anything that breaks the rules comes to our attention and we may delete inappropriate postings. Please treat other people with respect. You must not post anything that is abusive, indecent, unlawful or defamatory. Remember, you are personally liable for what you post on this site. If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us here.
* Your email address will not be displayed
** To avoid register now or login