Home
August 30, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
Revealed: how Brown and McConnell clashed over 10p tax rate
By Paul Hutcheon
Scottish Political Editor

JACK MCCONNELL warned Gordon Brown last year that abolishing the 10p rate of income tax would backfire and lose Labour support. The former first minister clashed with Brown during last year's Holyrood election campaign about the move, announced in Brown's last budget as chancellor.

The row undermined Labour's election strategy and led the party to focus on the SNP's local income tax plan.

Brown is facing a revolt among Labour MPs over his decision to fund a 2p cut in income tax by getting rid of the 10p starting rate. It benefits low-income earners and its abolition will increase the tax bill for the working poor.

The Sunday Herald has been told Brown and McConnell clashed during the Holyrood campaign after the then chancellor wanted his tax reforms to be central to Labour's fight for votes. McConnell was said to be critical of scrapping the 10p rate and believed a focus on the tax plans would backfire on Labour.

The pair were unable to resolve the issue and instead turned their attack on the SNP's plans to replace council tax with a local income tax. McConnell was also said to have raised concerns about changes to pensions announced in Brown's last budget.

A friend of McConnell's said: "Jack wasn't happy about the 10p policy and the effect on low-income earners. He and Brown didn't see eye to eye on parts of the Budget and how to make it a part of the Scottish election campaign."

The row comes on top of other revelations about Brown's apparent control-freakery after the Holyrood election, which the SNP won.

Brown, according to Sir Menzies Campbell's autobiography, tried to cobble together a third Labour/LibDem coalition deal. He also tried to block Alex Salmond's path to becoming first minister by suggesting Labour MSPs vote for either LibDem leader Nicol Stephen or Tory Annabel Goldie for the top job.

It is also understood Brown wanted McConnell to quit as Labour's Holyrood leader within days of the party's election defeat, and lobbied for Wendy Alexander to be anointed as Labour leader. This would have allowed her to be Labour's "fresh" candidate for first minister and removed any obstacles to another coalition deal.

However, the plan was thwarted after McConnell clung on as leader and the LibDems ruled out a deal. McConnell eventually quit in August and was replaced by Alexander in September.

Brown is expected to make concessions on the 10p rate when he addresses the STUC congress in Inverness this week. Several of his ministerial aides have criticised the policy, as have numerous backbench Labour MPs.

The SNP stepped up the pressure against the tax change at their spring conference yeterday, where they condemed the effect the policy will have on low-income workers.

A Labour spokesman said: "The 10p rate was introduced by the UK government to help tackle poverty and make work pay. It will benefit 16 million households across the UK, with the biggest gains going to the poorest 30% of people in our society."

A spokesman for the SNP said: "Jack McConnell was absolutely right. Gordon Brown should have heeded his warning and dropped this tax hike on 680,000 Scottish households. Labour will pay at the polls for this tax on the poor."

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: democrate, signing on on 1:17am Sun 20 Apr 08
Are we supposed to be surprised by this? Or by Wendy The Socialist's inability to comment on this policy, sorry, this theft?
Posted by: Matt, Southerly on 2:23am Sun 20 Apr 08
So, Gordon was warned what would happen, and went ahead, anyway.

The sign of a great man or an idiot.
Posted by: Mike, Edinburgh on 7:31am Sun 20 Apr 08
Oh where oh where is wendy. She goes to question time at the Parliament then disappears till the following Thursday.

Does she think that by not being soon, people will forget her illegal activities. Well wendy we Nats can guarantee that we will never forget, and no matter how long you hide we will keep refreshing the Peoples minds.

Resign Thief, you are not wanted here in Scotland. You are our shame.Its a pity your mother and father didnt give you and your lying brother a lot more skelps when you were being dragged up.
Posted by: paul, paisley on 7:31am Sun 20 Apr 08
'A Labour spokesman said: "The 10p rate was introduced by the UK government to help tackle poverty and make work pay . It will benefit 16 million households across the UK, with the biggest gains going to the poorest 30% of people in our society."


Honestly? Someone actually said that?!?!
Posted by: C, Glasgow on 7:32am Sun 20 Apr 08
Slack Jack "clashed" with Gordon Brown? Did he bump into him while he was licking his boots?
Posted by: wullie on 8:18am Sun 20 Apr 08
An increase in tax for the lowest paid.

Oh ho ho, that would be a policy from the party they call New Labour.

Aye Hard Labour - oh ho ho. The party of spin sleeze and squeeze.
Posted by: Curley Bill, the southwest on 9:02am Sun 20 Apr 08
Well, however history records Jack McConnell's era, the Scottish people should be eternally beholden to him for preventing the crook Alexander becoming First Minister.
Still, this doesn't quite erase the memory of his 'kilt'.
Posted by: Donald Anderson, glasgow on 10:04am Sun 20 Apr 08
English Gordon of Kaboul never forgave Union Jack for supporting the Scottish football team against England.

He even wants to go back into the Sudan
Posted by: heady on 11:52am Sun 20 Apr 08
So Jack is not quite as bad as Gordon - but he still stands against a local income tax which would relate tax to ability to pay rather than the Council Tax which does not. The McConnell's and very other over-paid family have profited hugely from the Council Tax at the expense of thte poor - they are skkum.
Posted by: bystander # 1, glasgow on 3:56pm Sun 20 Apr 08
Mike wrote:
Oh where oh where is wendy. She goes to question time at the Parliament then disappears till the following Thursday. Does she think that by not being soon, people will forget her illegal activities. Well wendy we Nats can guarantee that we will never forget, and no matter how long you hide we will keep refreshing the Peoples minds. Resign Thief, you are not wanted here in Scotland. You are our shame.Its a pity your mother and father didnt give you and your lying brother a lot more skelps when you were being dragged up.
mike - we espied wee wendy and her hubby wandering down the street last night in typical glasgow fashion. she was several paces ahead charging on....alas we must've just missed the domestic....but his swagger suggested he'd won.

skelped at work and at home - poor lassie!
Add your comment
Name:
Email: *
Location:
**
Security Image. Registered site users are not required to enter Security Image Information.
 
 e.g. 123-123
Comment:
Please note: All HTML tags will be ignored.
Format Text:

 
By posting a comment, I confirm that I have read and agree to the terms of use. Comments are not moderated but we will react if anything that breaks the rules comes to our attention and we may delete inappropriate postings. Please treat other people with respect. You must not post anything that is abusive, indecent, unlawful or defamatory. Remember, you are personally liable for what you post on this site. If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us here.
* Your email address will not be displayed
** To avoid register now or login