Home
August 20, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
Wendy Alexander: The End
Seven months after the Sunday Herald revealed her dodgy donation ... Wendy Alexander finally resigns
By journalist of the year, Paul Hutcheon

A CONFERENCE call to her shadow cabinet colleagues yesterday morning confirmed what had until then been simply speculation: Wendy Alexander would stand down as Labour's Holyrood leader before noon.

Her exit had been planned for more than 24 hours, the spur being the Parliament Standards Committee's recommendation on Thursday that Alexander serve a one-day ban for breaching Holyrood rules on non-declaration of gifts.

Her two closest allies, Labour MSPs Jackie Baillie and David Whitton, spent Friday in a series of meetings at John Smith House, the Scottish Labour HQ in Glasgow, trying to talk her out of resigning. Prime minister Gordon Brown, not a man without his own troubles, also urged her to stay on.

Alexander, tearful and nearly mute from laryngitis, was said to have been "persuaded" by her colleagues to back down. By 9pm, Baillie was telling journalists and MSPs that Alexander was staying; the Labour leader was walking away from the cliff.

However, a good sleep and the counsel offered by her husband, economist Brian Ashcroft, was sufficient to pull her back to her original position.

Hours later she announced her decision live on camera. "It is with deep regret that I write today to tender my resignation following the decisions of the Standards Committee this week," she said, holding back the tears.

Alexander's resignation has brought to a close a nine-month reign as Labour leader that was dogged by an endless run of stories about donations to her leadership campaign last August.

These culminated in Holyrood's Standards Committee, which upholds the MSPs' code of conduct, recommending Alexander serve a one-day suspension from parliament for failing to declare around £8000 in donations on her register of interest.

The committee, which was accused of making a "politically motivated" decision by Alexander's allies, agreed the sanction last week after backing the conclusion of standards commissioner Jim Dyer, whose own investigation into the Labour MSP found she had broken the parliament's rules on disclosing gifts.

In another twist, Alexander was also aware, at the time she was considering resignation, that she was the subject of another Dyer probe into her conduct.

After the commissioner had informed her in January of his initial finding that she had broken the rules on declaring gifts, a press release was put out in her name revealing details of Dyer's live inquiry - something that is clearly against the rules. She was facing the damaging prospect of the donations saga rolling on for months.

Ironically, it was the very leadership campaign that propelled Alexander into office that contained the seeds of her own downfall.

Last August, at a time when the Paisley North MSP was widely expected to succeed Jack McConnell as leader of the Labour party, Team Alexander decided to raise a war chest on the off-chance that another Labour MSP might mount a challenge.

Her key lieutenants - campaign manager Tom McCabe, Whitton as treasurer, as well as Baillie and fellow Labour MSP Charlie Gordon - held regular meetings that dealt with fundraising and strategy, but made two fatal errors.

The first was wilfully seeking donations of between £995 and £999, sums that suspiciously fell just below the Electoral Commission's public declaration level of £1000.

The other decision was to create a body called the Wendy Alexander Campaign, effectively a bank account that stored the money raised from the secret donors.

By seeking donations to the campaign, rather than to the MSP herself, Team Alexander believed the contributions would not have to be declared on the parliament's own register of interest.

In other words, Alexander's leadership campaign was structured in such a way that public disclosure, at both commission and parliamentary level, was unnecessary.

Team Alexander's actions were subsequently exposed in a series of investigations by the Sunday Herald that were given wind in separate inquiries into her campaign fund.

Her decision to accept an illegal £950 from Jersey-based businessman Paul Green overshadowed the first three months of her leadership and led to an inquiry by the Electoral Commission.

Although the watchdog declined to report Alexander to the procurator fiscal, the body did conclude that she had broken the law, a damaging fact for any politician.

But running parallel to the commission's investigation, which had attracted the attention of the UK media, was a much less high-profile probe by Dyer.

In December last year, at the height of the Green controversy, an SNP researcher wrote to the commissioner and urged him to investigate whether Alexander had broken Holyrood's rules by not declaring the campaign donations as gifts.

Dyer looked at the matter and, within weeks, concluded that Alexander had broken the rules on disclosure, a report he referred to procurator fiscal.

Although the prosecutor decided it was "not appropriate" to press charges against the Labour leader - a decision that appeared to close down the donations row - Dyer resumed his investigation with a view to issuing a report to the Standards Committee.

A donations row that had lain dormant for four months then flared up two weeks ago when the Sunday Herald revealed the contents of Dyer's report to the committee: in his view, a clear breach of the law had taken place.

The seven MSPs on the committee were then tasked with deciding whether to accept his findings and, if it did so, agreeing a sanction for Alexander.

A 5-2 majority decision last week backed Dyer's conclusion, which was followed by a narrower 4-3 decision last Thursday recommending a one-day suspension.

More damagingly, the committee's extended deliberations meant the full parliamentary vote could not take place until September: the donations row would hang over her for another two months.

Alexander's final hours in charge were, according to one Labour insider, a "messy and horrible" affair.

She had opted on Thursday night to resign as party leader, a decision Whitton and Baillie tried to overturn in frantic meetings at Labour HQ the following day.

A manic 24 hours saw Alexander being pulled in both directions after the duo insisted she could continue as leader and fight the ban.

Baillie, in particular, was keen for her to stay, a desire some party sources believe was motivated by a desire to retain her own position within the party as the leader's eyes and ears.

However, perhaps influenced by her husband, Alexander tendered her resignation to Scottish Labour general secretary Colin Smyth yesterday morning, and read it out at a press conference before noon.

Her defiant statement, in keeping with her past defence, went to some lengths to pass on the blame for her problems.

Despite breaking the law on declaring donations to the commission, Alexander claimed at the time that she had been "exonerated", a bizarre and self-serving interpretation of the facts.

This time she blamed the SNP. The Nationalists, she claimed, were responsible for "vexatious complaints" to the standards commissioner, and had "sought the prize of political victory with little thought to the standing of the parliament".

Her defence against the verdicts of the commissioner and the Standards Committee - that she was told by the parliament's clerks that registration was not unnecessary - was as weak as it was irrelevant.

Alexander had asked for advice from the clerks in November last year on the status of her donations, 60 days after some of the campaign cheques had been banked, despite the law clearly stating that MSPs have 30 days to declare gifts.

Put simply, Alexander asked for advice on registration well after she had already broken the rules, a fact that rendered any feedback from the Standards Committee as worthless.

However, while the protracted donations scandal has forced Alexander's resignation, a number of other issues contributed to the perception that her leadership was in trouble.

A series of shambolic performances at First Minister's Questions, coupled with the botched handling of her policy rethink on Scottish independence, gave the impression of a limping leader whose hold on power was far from secure.

Her nine-month stint also alienated colleagues who were among her staunchest supporters in the early days of her leadership.

McCabe, her campaign manager, had distanced himself from Alexander months before the Standards Committee verdict.

Duncan McNeil, the chair of the Labour group at Holyrood, was said to have turned down a senior post in Alexander's shadow administration, for reasons unexplained.

Even her Westminster allies, namely the prime minister and her brother Douglas, the international development secretary, were furious with her over the referendum debacle.

By the end, her dwindling band of supporters could be found in a small room in John Smith House trying to give Alexander's leadership the kiss of life.

Yesterday she ignored their advice and turned off her own life support machine.

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: Traquir, Alba on 11:37pm Sat 28 Jun 08
Well good riddance, let's move on, this Woman
has had much more press space than she ever merited.

Getting back to real politics
it sounds like Scottish by-election woes
are piling up for Maggie Broon.

"the SNP was preparing for a by-election because a Scottish Labour MP was ill."

And guess what it is NOT Glasgow
East MP David Marshall :)

see - tinyurl.com/4lsfow & tinyurl.com/4kf34m

In terms of the David Marshall by-election
we should start to leverage and
hone our collective Cybernat talents to
prepare the ground work for an SNP
victory. One good starting point will be
to have somebody pop down to Borders
book store in Glasgow's West End
and get a copy of "Halls of Infamy by James MacDonald. The book contains allegations
of yet more Labour sleaze and it
focuses on Glasgow City Hall which is
trying to actively ban the book
see - tinyurl.com/62zol5
The fact that a favorite Labour candidate
for David Marshall's seat is the
Glasgow City Hall Councillor George Ryan
from Ward 19 Shettleston, would make
the Halls of Infamy particularly topical.

Scottish Labour have disgraced Scotland
for way too long and need to be removed
from the political landscape so that
Scotland can prosper as a nation in her
own right. The fact that they are
now officially certified as a bunch
of loonies in addition to being
incompetent and mired in sleaze just
makes it all the more urgent to have
them committed and carried off sooner
rather than later.

Saor Alba
Posted by: Steve A, Independence for Scotland! on 11:39pm Sat 28 Jun 08
Take a bow Mr hutcheon its really good to know that we still have real journalists in Scotland.

If you are a Scotsman then i am proud to call myself a Scotsman!

Scotland is in your debt !
Posted by: Observer, Glasgow on 11:42pm Sat 28 Jun 08
Cue applause for Paul Hutcheon - who deserves the description investigative journalist. Well done Scotland's Woodward and Bernstein, if it wasn't for you, the Sunday Herald's editor and owners, and the Labour mole, no one would have known anything about this story. I hope you have a few well earned pints after this.

The rest of Scotland's media take note - this is what you are supposed to do. Find things out and publish them, without fear or favour.
Posted by: indyleith, Edinburgh on 11:48pm Sat 28 Jun 08
If we had a fair and balanced press and media, Wendy and her new liebour cronies wouldnt get the time of day. Paul Hutcheon has been a beacon of light in his pursuit for the plain and simple truth, not an easy task with the nasty party's smoke and mirrors. They are still officially in denial.

Hope she is not going for her holidays to an independent country - hypocrite.

She has been a total failure and is an embarrassment to Scotland. The first act of being an adult is taking responsibility for yourself and your actions, something that is way beyond her. Glad to say she will never be first minister just like Kerr, Gray, Curran and Jamieson. They are not worthy of the people or good enough. They are a disgrace. Independence for Scotland has now accelerated and they are yesterdays news.

Posted by: karin, glasgow on 11:53pm Sat 28 Jun 08
it was paul hutcheon wot did it.

well done that man.

ps any chance of you stepping into the political editors job at the herald now that dougie fraser is going.
Posted by: Arnold Codger on 11:58pm Sat 28 Jun 08
Alan Cochrane - Telegraph
Even the manner of her going was a kick in the teeth for Gordon Brown, the man to whom Wendy Alexander owed everything. He has been her mentor and prop throughout her political career, yet time and time again this headstrong and overconfident young lady has let him down.

Never more so than in her sudden decision to resign as leader of the Labour Party in the Scottish Parliament yesterday, at the end of a week in which Mr Brown had suffered a by-election result that saw his party trail in fifth behind the BNP.

But Alexander saw nothing of this. Always the epicentre of her own world, she thought only of herself. She says she went because of the "politically biased" decision of the Scottish Parliament to suspend her over her non-declaration of campaign donations, but few will believe that.

advertisement
Much more likely is that she went because the realisation finally dawned that she wasn't up to the job of battling the super-slick SNP leader and First Minister, Alex Salmond. He has been running rings around her ever since she was first elected last autumn.

News: Wendy Alexander resigns
Read more from Alan Cochrane
Friends and family have been urging her to resign for some time now, long before Thursday's decision at Holyrood to suspend her.

There are many who reckon the suspension was merely the excuse she needed to quit, opt for a quiet life and spend more time with her husband and three-year-old twins. Any effect this might have on Labour's and Gordon Brown's fortunes were not something that concerned her.

Ever loyal to his friend, when Brown heard on Friday that his protégé was considering a snap resignation, he telephoned her. Significantly, he didn't say "don't go", but instead said "don't go now".

He urged her to spend more time with her family, go on holiday and think things through. His concern was that his old friend would act hastily, only to repent at leisure. And, perhaps more importantly, he did not want Scottish Labour convulsed all summer in a bitter new leadership contest at a time when his own fortunes continue to plummet in the polls. A period of calm in that troubled party could do no harm.

However, the Prime Minister's appeal was ignored. As Labour insiders insisted, it was an act typical of this lady.

It was Brown who first pushed Alexander into politics; after all he knew her well. She was not only the sister of Douglas, his long-time parliamentary aide and now cabinet colleague, she was also, like him, the child of a Church of Scotland minister. He reckoned that they shared a "moral compass".

Alexander's political career began as a political adviser to Donald Dewar, Scottish Secretary in Tony Blair's 1997 government, and continued as a senior minister in the Labour/Liberal Democrat coalition following the establishment of the Scottish Parliament in 1999.

It was Brown who, behind the scenes, was urging Alexander onwards and upwards. Unfortunately, she was a decidedly mediocre minister, misjudging the mood of the country in seeking to repeal the ban on teaching homosexuality in schools and being reported to senior civil servants for "bullying" her officials.

In spite of these lapses, Brown wanted Alexander anointed as Scotland's First Minister. However, after Dewar died and his successor, Henry McLeish, resigned following an expenses muddle, Alexander bottled out of a leadership contest against Jack McConnell, an avowed Blairite, telephoning the then Chancellor at 4am at his Fife home to tell him that she'd decided not to stand.

That retreat put enormous strain on their relationship and although she was at the heart of Labour's campaign for the Scottish Parliament elections last year, the contest saw Labour lose its grip on Scotland for the first time in 50 years.

When McConnell stood down, Alexander - thanks to Brownite pressure - was declared the sole candidate: the way was clear for her to assume the leadership. But right from the outset it was a disaster, and not only because of the interminable rows over an unlawful offshore donation to her campaign that involved the Electoral Commission, Strathclyde Police and Scotland's prosecuting authorities.

Never a match for the populist skills of Salmond, Alexander and Scottish Labour floundered in their role as an opposition party. And although an acknowledged - mostly by herself - intellectual, she had no facility for the cut and thrust of political debate, baffling even her own side with her often impenetrable jargon and lists of incomprehensible facts and figures.
Posted by: JWil, Lanarkshire on 12:03am Sun 29 Jun 08
I wonder if the Electoral Commission still thinks it wasn't in the public interest to take action against Wendy?
Posted by: Wardog, Buckie on 12:11am Sun 29 Jun 08
JWil wrote:
I wonder if the Electoral Commission still thinks it wasn't in the public interest to take action against Wendy?

It really puts the Electoral Commission in a bad light - ineffectual and toothless.
Posted by: Arnold Codger on 12:11am Sun 29 Jun 08
Thank you Paul Hutcheon on good journalism on this important political matter. I see an award coming your way. Forgive me posting of the Telegraph article but i'm happy tonight. I think Wendy done the right thing and ignored the advice others.
Posted by: council worker, edinburgh on 12:13am Sun 29 Jun 08
i have listened to wendy's pathetic, pitiful and vitriolic resignation speech and the interviews with her political commentator friends and media and unionist supporters.
i frequently post on these sites and as a council lavvy cleaner, all i have to say is: (i smell ****!)
Posted by: Traquir, Alba on 12:16am Sun 29 Jun 08

What could be more sweet than a couple
of Scottish MP by-election wins for
the SNP ? Well how about a defection that
would work :) How about this one previously
predicted by the impressive
and very reliable
Scottish journalist Paul Hutcheon.
Quite likely all that he got wrong was
the timing and likely now would be
the perfect time before the Labour
ship sinks completely.

"Labour MP poised for defection to SNP POLITICS: SECRET TALKS"

tinyurl.com/5xz22y
Posted by: nostress, grangemouth on 12:21am Sun 29 Jun 08
In a statement, Ms Alexander's brother Douglas Alexander, the secretary of state for international development, said: "This has been a very tough decision in very difficult circumstances and I understand Wendy's characteristic instinct to put the Labour Party interests first.

That in a nutshell sums up the whole problem with the Labour Party - and they STILL don't get it! She put the interests of the Labour Party first - NOT those of her constituents, NOT those of Scotland - just those of the Party! And they wonder why they are despised the length and breadth of this country
Posted by: Scott, Inverness on 12:22am Sun 29 Jun 08
I applaud you Paul a very good article we now know the truth I only wonder what spin Douglas will put on this in the Herald on Monday,as for Mr Cochrane the NAT basher no thank you I would not turn my back to him.
Posted by: Wallace, Perth on 12:29am Sun 29 Jun 08
Traquir, I can't think of any of the current crop of Scottish Labour MSP's who could be considered an asset to the SNP. If any of them ever do decide to defect to the SNP, I would rather they did so because of a sincere change of political heart, and not just because they're deserting a sinking Labour ship.

That type of "convert" could never be relied upon and would smack of the kind of current Labour politician who is in it for what they can get out of it, not for anything they could contribute. For example, would you now accept Wendy Alexander on board if she now decided to grace the SNP with the benefit of her massive intellect and talents? I thought not!!!
Posted by: Dave, Cathcart on 12:29am Sun 29 Jun 08
Does anybody know where Charlie Gordon, Cathcart MSP, stands in this scenario?

He was involved at the beginning but seems to have faded into the background.
Posted by: Wallace, Perth on 12:35am Sun 29 Jun 08
Nostress, I agree with you about why Scottish (and UK) Labour are in such a mess. But I disagree with Wendy Alexander's brother that she put her party first in this instance. She put herself first, as she always does. Her boss, North British Broon, asked her to stay at least for the time being, as the UK party is in such dire straits right now. She refused and instead went her own typically selfish way in a fit of pique, unable to accept responsibility for her actions.
Posted by: Traquir, Alba on 12:36am Sun 29 Jun 08
Wallace wrote:
Traquir, I can\'t think of any of the current crop of Scottish Labour MSP\'s who could be considered an asset to the SNP. If any of them ever do decide to defect to the SNP, I would rather they did so because of a sincere change of political heart, and not just because they\'re deserting a sinking Labour ship.

That type of \"convert\" could never be relied upon and would smack of the kind of current Labour politician who is in it for what they can get out of it, not for anything they could contribute. For example, would you now accept Wendy Alexander on board if she now decided to grace the SNP with the benefit of her massive intellect and talents? I thought not!!!
I think you are correct it would be a challenge
to find any of the current MSPs that
you could trust and value on a defection.
You are also very right that a sincere
change of political heart would be a
key trait needed for any such defection
in particular putting Scotland first.
However in this case Paul was talking about
an MP not an MSP which would be a much
bigger defection. That said your points
still stand as the quality of Labour's
MPs is not any better than their
MSPs - can you just imagine if
it was a turncoat like Cairns. What
a stomach churning thought I think
such a defection would refused :)

Slainte Mhor
Posted by: Ronald, Glasgow on 12:37am Sun 29 Jun 08
I now see that Mr Paul Hutcheon is being rightly described as "Journalist of the Year!"
Glad to see that someone, somewhere has been listening to me. lol
When one compares Hucheons output compared to
that of those viscious, evil, right-wing hacks like Herr Frazer and Herr Young - well it clearly highlights how utterly pathetic
they are. And like THE NEW-LABOUR PROJECT
their credibility is completly shot!
And when Hutcheon clearly spells out above the
sheer duplicity displayed by the Alexander gang, then one is left wondering just how the hell the fiscal failed to set in train a prosecution, against the criminal cabal.
Posted by: Jimbo on 12:44am Sun 29 Jun 08
Traquir wrote:
Well good riddance, let\'s move on, this Woman has had much more press space than she ever merited. Getting back to real politics it sounds like Scottish by-election woes are piling up for Maggie Broon. \"the SNP was preparing for a by-election because a Scottish Labour MP was ill.\" And guess what it is NOT Glasgow East MP David Marshall :) see - tinyurl.com/4lsfow & tinyurl.com/4kf34m In terms of the David Marshall by-election we should start to leverage and hone our collective Cybernat talents to prepare the ground work for an SNP victory. One good starting point will be to have somebody pop down to Borders book store in Glasgow\'s West End and get a copy of \"Halls of Infamy by James MacDonald. The book contains allegations of yet more Labour sleaze and it focuses on Glasgow City Hall which is trying to actively ban the book see - tinyurl.com/62zol5 The fact that a favorite Labour candidate for David Marshall\'s seat is the Glasgow City Hall Councillor George Ryan from Ward 19 Shettleston, would make the Halls of Infamy particularly topical. Scottish Labour have disgraced Scotland for way too long and need to be removed from the political landscape so that Scotland can prosper as a nation in her own right. The fact that they are now officially certified as a bunch of loonies in addition to being incompetent and mired in sleaze just makes it all the more urgent to have them committed and carried off sooner rather than later. Saor Alba
Aye Traquir,

it looks like we could possibly be campaigning on the streets of Glenrothes as well as Shettleston.

The MP for Glenrothes, John MacDougall, has been diagnosed as having mesothelioma and may well tender his resignation. Despite the serious nature of the disease, there is hope. Every year, doctors and scientists worldwide are developing new treatments and making new discoveries that help to improve the chance of survival and the patient’s quality of life. Let us hope that this applies to John MacDougall and I send my sincere best wishes to him and his family.

If Mr MacDougall does resign (he was reported as being ready to stand down in October if Broon called a snap election), and Marshall already having done so, I wonder if Labour will fight both elections at the same time or contest them separately as they're now a bit thin on the ground these days when it comes to finding activists.

Some people have claimed that it is rather callous of the other parties to already be preparing to fight an election contest in Glenrothes, but that is the nature of politics. The Labour Party started choosing a replacement for John Smith when they heard of his condition.

How John MacDougall voted on key issues since 2001:

Has never voted on a transparent Parliament.

Voted moderately for introducing a smoking ban.

Voted strongly for introducing ID cards.

Voted very strongly for introducing foundation hospitals.

Voted strongly for introducing student top-up fees.

Voted very strongly for Labour's anti-terrorism laws.

Voted very strongly for the Iraq war.

Voted strongly against an investigation into the Iraq war.

Voted very strongly for replacing Trident.

Voted moderately for the hunting ban.

Voted moderately for equal gay rights.

I have no doubt that as a person, John MacDougall is a decent man, but as a politician it would appear he is from the same mould as David Cairns

Posted by: Wallace, Perth on 12:45am Sun 29 Jun 08
Traquair, wait till we see the infusion of talent that'll flood onto the Scottish Labour benches in Holyrood after the next General Election. We could see the likes of North British Broon, McChattering Cairns, Wee Dougie Alexander and Two-Jobbies Browne gracing the benches behind Big Jackie and Baron Barlinnie Fuchs! We could even have Squeaker Martin as our Presiding Officer. Nightmare scenario, or what?
Posted by: Traquir, Alba on 12:52am Sun 29 Jun 08
Wallace wrote:
Traquair, wait till we see the infusion of talent that'll flood onto the Scottish Labour benches in Holyrood after the next General Election. We could see the likes of North British Broon, McChattering Cairns, Wee Dougie Alexander and Two-Jobbies Browne gracing the benches behind Big Jackie and Baron Barlinnie Fuchs! We could even have Squeaker Martin as our Presiding Officer. Nightmare scenario, or what?
Now that truly would be a nightmare, I'm not
sure I will be able to sleep tonight
with that image in my head :) Of
course after the next Scottish election
there will be a lot less Labour MSPs
so I guess they can just be viewed
as some sort of small Barnum style freaks
sideshow which of course we should
treat with compassion, but they would
really be quite harmless.
Posted by: bully wee alba, Edinburgh on 12:56am Sun 29 Jun 08
wendy who ?
Posted by: Jimbo on 12:57am Sun 29 Jun 08
Hi Traquir,

What could be more sweet than a couple
of Scottish MP by-election wins for
the SNP?


Shettleston and Glenrothes will be two hard nuts to crack.

Shettleston would require a 22% swing to the SNP and Glenrothes would require a swing to the SNP of 14.5%.
Posted by: Jock Politicaljunkie, Glasgow on 1:07am Sun 29 Jun 08
Mole: 1 - UUendy: 0

Go on Paul - who WAS the Mole??
We're all itching to find out.
Heard a rumour that it was Cathy J.
Posted by: Morag, Peeblesshire on 1:07am Sun 29 Jun 08

You know, speaking as a daughter of the manse, I'mk getting heartily sick of hearing Brown and the Alexander duo's presbyterian heritage trumpeted. When I think of the harm that bunch of self-serving hypocrites have done to my country, I start to consider the most unChristian retaliation.

Please don't tar all of us ministers' children with the same brush. Some of us are quite decent and productive citizens.

And I'm very very sorry indeed to hear about Mr. MacDougal. My own father died of mesothelioma (contracted working as an engineer in the Clyde shipyards before he studied for the ministry), and it's not something I'd wish on my worst enemy.

Sadly, if that's the diagnosis, the Glenrothes by-election cannot be long delayed. Indeed, I hope it's soon, to give the poor man as much as possible of his remaining months with his family.

Posted by: Traquir, Alba on 1:17am Sun 29 Jun 08
Jimbo wrote:
Hi Traquir,

What could be more sweet than a couple
of Scottish MP by-election wins for
the SNP?


Shettleston and Glenrothes will be two hard nuts to crack.

Shettleston would require a 22% swing to the SNP and Glenrothes would require a swing to the SNP of 14.5%.
You are very correct, and the SNP will need
all of our help to pull both of these off.
A key ingredient though is that
we have a fire in our bellies
whereas they have no passion
and no drive, and most importantly no
ambition nor confidence in Scotland as
a nation in her own right. Leveraged
properly this will win the day.

Also the precedent of Crewe and Nantwich
with a 17.6% swing does help. Also having
Labour finish 5th behind the BNP at
Henley shows just how far they have fallen.
tinyurl.com/44ksjd

At this point I truly believe that Labour
is on the verge of complete annihilation and
these by-elections could be fundamental
in pushing them over the edge. The Labour
Party is almost bankrupt and their
membership in Scotland is plummeting with
the likelihood that SNP membership within
the next couple of years will
overtake theirs for the first time ever
which would a massive sea change on
the political landscape. The "Scottish"
Labour party at this point has abandoned
almost all of their Socialist principals
and the damage they have done to Scotland
over the last five decades is
immeasurable. From the ashes a true
Socialist party will have the opportunity
to emerge which hopefully will add
Independence to their aims. In the
meantime we should all help put
the final nails in the coffin
of the so called "Scottish" Labour
party - they are an absolute disgrace
to Scotland.
Posted by: JWil, Lanarkshire on 1:19am Sun 29 Jun 08
Dave, Cathcart on 12:29am today
Does anybody know where Charlie Gordon, Cathcart MSP, stands in this scenario? He was involved at the beginning but seems to have faded into the background.


Charlie Gordon? If you look down the page you will see that he is still causing mischeive for the SNP by trying to give Councils control over allocation of bus routes.
Posted by: Supershug, Eaglesham on 1:23am Sun 29 Jun 08
Dave wrote:
Does anybody know where Charlie Gordon, Cathcart MSP, stands in this scenario?

He was involved at the beginning but seems to have faded into the background.
Exactly, Dave. Come one, Hutch, you know the score - send Starsky round to his front door and take him down as he runs for cover out the back way!

Seriously, though, the praise lavished on Mr Hutcheon is fully merited and I hope the role of Charlie Gordon is put under a similar microscope.

Ironically, it was the very leadership campaign that propelled Alexander into office that contained the seeds of her own downfall.


Oh, it's ironic alright - raising money for a contest that was never held!
Posted by: subrosa on 1:41am Sun 29 Jun 08
Some years ago I gave up knocking doors but I'd be willing to do it for these by-elections. In fact I may just enjoy it but I'll have to order another pair of steel finger capped gloves. Someone just tell me where to report.
Posted by: nostress, grangemouth on 2:07am Sun 29 Jun 08
Wallace, Perth wrote: She put herself first, as she always does. Her boss, North British Broon, asked her to stay at least for the time being, as the UK party is in such dire straits right now. She refused and instead went her own typically selfish way in a fit of pique, unable to accept responsibility for her actions.

No argument from me there Wallace. I well remember Maxton on re-election in Cathcart some years back, rubbing his hands in glee and exclaiming that was his pension sorted now! For too long now, the decent, caring folk who entrusted this bunch of shysters with their vote have been betrayed shamelessly.
Posted by: Proud to be Scottish, Brisbane on 2:11am Sun 29 Jun 08
This is the beginning of the end for the nats little popularity spike.

Wendy was the victim of political prejudice. The nats couldn't quite handle an independently thinking women at the helm of another party. This is a sad day for standards in Scottish political life. The history books will show her as a person of great fortitude and skill. Scotland is the poorer this morning.

However the nats have no more mud to throw. Two by election wins against the SNP will be reported and widely perceived as the turning point and the high-noon of nat popularity.

Enjoy the next few weeks all you cyber-gnats. The end is nigh.
Posted by: nostress, grangemouth on 2:20am Sun 29 Jun 08
Wayhay PtbS in Brisbane...it's all your fault cobber...if you'd stayed she'd still be in place, but once she heard that even you'd fled the country, well, that was the straw that broke the camel's back I'm afraid...
Posted by: Highlander, Scotland on 2:23am Sun 29 Jun 08
You have to read this. Brilliant insight:

http://www.timesonli
ne.co.uk/tol/news/uk
/scotland/article423
2700.ece

Posted by: Wardog, Buckie on 2:24am Sun 29 Jun 08
Proud to be Scottish, Brisbane on 2:11am today

On holiday are we?

Can just see you lying out on the sand, union jack towel, cheap ibm laptop and a bottle of iron bru.


"This is the beginning of the end...."


Yes it is PtBS.

What will be this week, full fiscal autonomy or returning to the fold of London control?

"Wendy was the victim"


Poor Wendy, a victim of those bullying, sexiest, ageist SNP types.... nothing whatsoever to do with her repeatedly breaking the Parliament's rules on funding.... have you found that mole yet PtbS, are you in charge of the internal enquiry?

"no more mud to throw"


Oh believe me PtBS, there is plenty mud to sling, haven't you read about the Shettleston MP's alleged mis-use of his Commons expenses to pay members of his family?

The end is nigh.


It sure is... meltdown, what meltdown?



Posted by: Wardog, Buckie on 2:28am Sun 29 Jun 08
Proud to be Scottish, Brisbane on 2:11am today

Is it just me.... every time I see a PtbS post, I can't help but thinking of the Col Bogey March .....


Posted by: juankerr, Scotland on 2:31am Sun 29 Jun 08
Proud to be Scottish wrote:
This is the beginning of the end for the nats little popularity spike. Wendy was the victim of political prejudice. The nats couldn't quite handle an independently thinking women at the helm of another party. This is a sad day for standards in Scottish political life. The history books will show her as a person of great fortitude and skill. Scotland is the poorer this morning. However the nats have no more mud to throw. Two by election wins against the SNP will be reported and widely perceived as the turning point and the high-noon of nat popularity. Enjoy the next few weeks all you cyber-gnats. The end is nigh.
Is that you burning your £350k, look at my wad?

Try not to get eaten by a pack of dingos.....toodle pip old boy.
Posted by: Wardog, Buckie on 2:34am Sun 29 Jun 08
Proud to be Scottish, Brisbane on 2:11am today

The history books....


I'm afraid they will record that one Ms W Alexander MSP, Leader of the Labour Group In Holyrood was found to have breached the Standards Code and was punished with a proposed one day suspension.

She resigned.

She was then subsequently reprimanded for leaking details of her case to the press which is strictly forbidden, this precipitated her departure from politics altogether..... and everyone lived happily ever after



Posted by: subrosa on 2:37am Sun 29 Jun 08
From the Observer (a snippet)
Ex-Downing Street staffer John McTernan, now an aide to Des Browne, the Defence and Scottish Secretary, is said to have nurtured a long-term interest in the seat. But he may be ruled out given that he was interviewed by police in the cash for honours scandal, although he was cleared of any wrongdoing. Lesley Quinn, the outgoing Scottish Labour general secretary, is also tipped as a possible contender.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 2:39am Sun 29 Jun 08

Proud To Be Skittish
This is the beginning of the end for the nats little popularity spike.
Coincidentally, the word "****" also comes to mind when thinking of Internet trolls.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 2:40am Sun 29 Jun 08
Pr*ck
Posted by: Steve A, Independence for Scotland! on 2:41am Sun 29 Jun 08
PtbS
Why dont you try and do the Harold while your in bonga bonga land ?
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 2:44am Sun 29 Jun 08
Hutcheon
She ignored advice and turned off her own life support machine.
At least we know she believed in euthanasia.
Posted by: Proud to be Scottish, Brisbane on 2:46am Sun 29 Jun 08
Crickey it's Jaun and Wardog!

Pass me a penne recipe!

Wardog - you seem to be slightly challenged when it comes to intellectual capacity. You take several posts to address one of mine - are you sure you should be up this late?, no doubt you'll take another 1/2 dozen posts to admonish this comment.

Juan - I'm working actually (will be tomorrow)

The facts are plain for all to see:-

No wrongdoing

Followed the clerks advice

Not guilty verdict from the EC

Jim Dyer is a biased nat, his actions can only be viewed through that prism.

Those are the facts of the matter, no amount of fancy nat spinning can change that.

Posted by: Proud to be Scottish, Brisbane on 2:49am Sun 29 Jun 08
LA

Would you like me to post THE link?

Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 3:19am Sun 29 Jun 08
Proud To Be Skittish
Would you like me to post THE link?
She parked her car on double yellow lines at the weekend assuming a parking warden would not pass by. When she slept in on the Monday and found a fine on her windscreen she sought guidance, affecting the excuse of ignorance about traffic regulations, the very ones her party had composed and instituted.

For those who would defend her, now is the time to remain silent.



Her act is indictative of the character of Scottish Labour.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Eduinburgh on 3:21am Sun 29 Jun 08
Proud To Be Skittish
Those are the facts of the matter, no amount of fancy Labour "mea never culpa" spinning can change that.
Posted by: Donald Anderson, glasgow on 3:34am Sun 29 Jun 08
She couldn't even leave with a shred of dignity, but kept up her petty tirade, blaming the SNP bogeyman to the bitter end. Still, she can look forward to £50,000 per annum pension to console her retirement and whatever perks and houndout jobs feeble Labour can still spring on their failures.

Now, just look at the gene pool left. Nor much for Labour to choose from. One numpty goes and another numpty will hold the poison chalice. They just don't get it. The time has come for all anti Scottish parties to leave Scotland. Even Broon cannot pull his North Nationalism off in the belly of the beast, in his beloved London.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 3:43am Sun 29 Jun 08
Donald Anderson
Still, she can look forward to MSP pension to console her retirement
Pretty good personal result, all things considered.
Posted by: clochoderic on 4:11am Sun 29 Jun 08
Ptbs :your assertions can not stand any reasonable challenge - why do you persist in defending this discredited harpie?
She is the most obvious example of nepotism and corruption laid bare for the electorate to examine yet.
Her nemesis is long overdue and I anticipate fondly my chance to patronise her as she scans my purchases at the new Linwood Tesco.
Posted by: Boston John, USA on 4:49am Sun 29 Jun 08
Fat, ugly, arrogant and a thief... "so, you've met Wendy then??"

Good riddance.
Posted by: alex, dumbarton on 6:53am Sun 29 Jun 08
Concise, Precise and Damning. Not only does this terrific piece of journalism show how vain Alexander is, her so called friends and collegues don't come out in a good light either. In fact going by some of their interpretations of the rules, maybe they should all be looked at closer.
Posted by: Astonished, Inverclyde on 7:10am Sun 29 Jun 08
The electoral commission must be investigated, there is no longer any place in Scotland for labour bagmen.


Wardog said :
Proud to be Scottish, Brisbane on 2:11am today

Is it just me.... every time I see a PtbS post, I can't help but thinking of the Col Bogey March .....
Brilliant !
Posted by: paul on 7:32am Sun 29 Jun 08
Proud to be Scottish wrote:
This is the beginning of the end for the nats little popularity spike.

Wendy was the victim of political prejudice. The nats couldn't quite handle an independently thinking women at the helm of another party. This is a sad day for standards in Scottish political life. The history books will show her as a person of great fortitude and skill. Scotland is the poorer this morning.

However the nats have no more mud to throw. Two by election wins against the SNP will be reported and widely perceived as the turning point and the high-noon of nat popularity.

Enjoy the next few weeks all you cyber-gnats. The end is nigh.
Come on Douglas! Just cos your sister has failed - you don't have to get involved.
Posted by: tb303, Correctness on 8:02am Sun 29 Jun 08
Wardog wrote:
Proud to be Scottish, Brisbane on 2:11am today On holiday are we? Can just see you lying out on the sand, union jack towel, cheap ibm laptop and a bottle of iron bru.
\"This is the beginning of the end....\"
Yes it is PtBS. What will be this week, full fiscal autonomy or returning to the fold of London control?
\"Wendy was the victim\"
Poor Wendy, a victim of those bullying, sexiest, ageist SNP types.... nothing whatsoever to do with her repeatedly breaking the Parliament\'s rules on funding.... have you found that mole yet PtbS, are you in charge of the internal enquiry?
\"no more mud to throw\"
Oh believe me PtBS, there is plenty mud to sling, haven\'t you read about the Shettleston MP\'s alleged mis-use of his Commons expenses to pay members of his family?
The end is nigh.
It sure is... meltdown, what meltdown?
Oh dear.......don't disagree with some of the views........BUT...I

BM laptops ain't cheap......(also they're Lenovo these days)
Posted by: heavy, Glasgow on 8:15am Sun 29 Jun 08
It is political scumbags like Alexander and her brother that have done so much harm
to Labour. Most of the conspirators who aided Blair and now Brown to carry out their
NWO agenda have never been interested in helping the ordinary folk of Scotland only
on turning our once proud country into a surveillance and police state.

New Labour has been taken over by fascists who do not give a **** about the freedoms of our people but more interested in a sinister agenda of turning us into amiable slaves for their doing. Anyone of any worth was thrown out of old Labour when Blair turned NEW(World Order) Labour into a Tory party Mk2 .

It is bad enough the men recruited for this EVIL agenda but were do they get the women?
Alexander pales next to Jaci Smith,Harriet Hatemen , Ruth Kelly, Hazel Blears and the other toxic dolls aiding and abetting the fear and intimidation Brown is using to push through his sinister agenda.

There are many vulnerable individuals who live in constant fear of what they have planned next . But only if we let them get away with this ORDER out of chaos they are creating and they KNOW the outcome no matter how stupid or ridiculous they look when they carry out these plans .

There is a master plan here that few have truly grasped, the staged plan to bring
in a one world government, if not by consent, then by starving us all into submission.
Its a pity there aren't enough Scots to see the bigger picture . Brown will soon have a
replacement toxic doll for Alexander who will carry out his bidding without recourse.

LJPR LEGAL JUDICIAL POLITICAL REFORMERS

Posted by: Wullie on 8:16am Sun 29 Jun 08
An informative and balanced piece of journalism from Mr Hutcheon.

clear and honest reporting is what readers look for. Not the censored Pravda style journalism that has been all too prevalent in the Herald over recent months
Posted by: somerferg, perth on 8:31am Sun 29 Jun 08

Boo Hoo bye bye satchmo - I'll miss you NOT
Posted by: JABRE, FEARN on 8:39am Sun 29 Jun 08
PAUL--I salute you!!
A journalist who deals with the facts as they are and not spun to suit political affiliation--keep up the good work and thanks to the Herald for printing. I may even consider buying again
Posted by: william munn, Hamilton on 9:12am Sun 29 Jun 08
I know George Ryan as he was once my union representative. Wasn't he disciplined (should have been prosecuted) by Labour for some housing fiddle involving him and his father?
Posted by: Politically-incorrec t Man, The Real World on 9:19am Sun 29 Jun 08
Rejoice, rejoice, the Witch is dead!
Rejoice, rejoice, the Witch is dead!
Rejoice, rejoice, the Witch is dead!
Rejoice, rejoice, the Witch is dead!
Rejoice, rejoice, the Witch is dead!

Beware the new witch will come because they are all (yes all) exactly the same, all heads of the same Hydra, some more skilful than others, some more attractive, some with siren song but ALL part of the same beast.

The SNP heads will sway and hypnotise just as did the Blair pod with promises of great deeds and treasures in store but they are part of the same beast, part of the same parasitic Hydra whose tentacles stretch out into our pockets plucking riches from us and secreting them away in the coffers of the rich.

Bilderberg still rules!
Posted by: george alexander, north lanarkshire on 9:23am Sun 29 Jun 08
Re: Halls of Infamy

I popped into Borders yesterday and asked for this book. The assistant couldn't find it anywhere on the system.

Posted by: Kenny Patrick on 9:25am Sun 29 Jun 08
"Work as if you live in the early days of a better nation"

What a pathetic approach from the Herald, it just shows what a poor wee nation we are as opposed to the vision offered by the above quotation. The Herald so proud that it uncovered Scotland's own donation scandal £8000 to a leadership campaign that did not happen.
Posted by: Lachlan, Stirling on 9:28am Sun 29 Jun 08
The premature death of Donald Dewar has cast a long shadow over the Labour Party in Scotland.

All Dewar's successors have simply not been of his calibre! The Labour Party in Scotland has been devoid of talented people for the leadership, and totally complacent about the Nationalist threat.

This time the Labour Party in Scotland had better make sure it ELECTS a good candidate for the leadership, instead of shoe-horning a party appartchi(c)k into the job?

This could well be be Scottish Labour's last chance to find a suitable leader or the parliament created for Unionists might become permanently occupied by Nationalists?


Posted by: Supershug, Eaglesham on 9:49am Sun 29 Jun 08
The premature death of Donald Dewar has cast a long shadow over the Labour Party in Scotland.

All Dewar's successors have simply not been of his calibre!


Yeah - his actions on the parliament building and his selection of Wendy and Douglas Alexander on the grounds he was their dad's best pal testifies to that.
Posted by: westcoast, Ayrshire on 9:50am Sun 29 Jun 08
Kenny Patrick wrote:
\\\"Work as if you live in the early days of a better nation\\\" What a pathetic approach from the Herald, it just shows what a poor wee nation we are as opposed to the vision offered by the above quotation. The Herald so proud that it uncovered Scotland's own donation scandal £8000 to a leadership campaign that did not happen.
It seems to most people I 've spoken with that WA had no choice but to go. She had the choice of going with some dignity, but chose to go with none at all. This episode sends out the right messages. It shows that where there is the will, the press can hold politicians to account for appropriate reasons. It also shows that there is within parliament the will and the ability to require those who are elected to live within the rules. WA clearly showed from the very outset her deliberate intent to subvert the rules. The rest is simply layer of deceit on top of layer of self deception. Godd riddance. Hope the rest are paying attention - including the London pig trough. I wonder if Kenny Patrick can tell us how WA was living up to the vision?
Posted by: Ronald, Glasgow on 9:55am Sun 29 Jun 08
Highlander - Thanks for pointing out that times online article - its a cracker !!
Posted by: pehman, sussex on 9:56am Sun 29 Jun 08
Wendy wendy it's all about wendy, has anybody got any real news

whats the story about Dougie Fraser ?

PS, well BLOODY WELL DONE PAUL HUTCHEON, STANDING OVATION, and if I see you in Shettleston, I would be pleased to shake your hand and buy you a drink, thankyou
Posted by: Disgusted Dorothy, Glasgow on 10:18am Sun 29 Jun 08