Home
August 20, 2008 Est 1999 Scotland's award-winning independent newspaper
It’s not just the weather maps that are skewed
Kate Smith on BBC bias

THE NEWS that the BBC is scaling back on its already cigarette-paper thin coverage of the Edinburgh festivals, the world's biggest live arts event, chimes with the current overall level of coverage of Scotland and all things Scottish by the British Broadcasting Corporation. That is, to look at the BBC news this week you would think that Scotland doesn't exist. Or perhaps it's right next to the Falkland Islands on the priority list.

We in Scotland are already familiar with the BBC's squinty weather maps which, by virtue of their tilted angle, show us every cove and bay on the south coast of England yet leave us unable to distinguish the weather between Glasgow and Dundee. But now UK news programmes run start-to-finish skewed news coverage of SATS results (England), council strikes (England, Wales and Northern Ireland), a reduction in crime figures (England and Wales) while never reporting the Scottish equivalent.

It could be chagrin arising from the recent BBC Trust's optimistically entitled "impartiality report" which found, ahem, a strong partiality to an anti-Scottish bias. On the other hand, it could be the low level of commissioning of Scottish programmes - said to be as little as 3% of overall output. Perhaps such lack of Scottish programming has resulted in an "off the screen, out of mind" mentality from BBC executives?

Then of course there's the Scottish Broadcasting Commission report due soon. Although led by former BBC man Blair Jenkins, it could be causing anxiety at the BBC HQ. Maybe by being so weakened in broadcasting output terms, Scotland carries no clout. Expecting they may be evicted from the Big Brother house come independence, the BBC may have already flitted.

One thing is for sure, the political landscape has become more pluralistic since devolution. Perhaps this bias is all accidentally-on-purpose and researchers, producers and editors think "devolution has made it all too tricky to remember what's going on in Scotland It's too much detail which ruins the pacing of the news story and who cares what's going on up there anyway?"

The "male gaze" was used to describe all those shoot-em-up car chase 80s Hollywood films in which the film's producers automatically assumed the viewer was a man. The BBC has a "London gaze". It assumes its audience resides only in the south-east.

So maybe the Edinburgh festivals coverage is just the hapless bystander of the creeping erasure of Scotland from the BBC. That would be a pity, because six years ago the corporation was boasting of its most comprehensive coverage of the festivals ever.

It's not about cash. The BBC is sending an army of producers and presenters to the Olympics in Beijing at the licence fee payers' expense. More than 150 at last count. Last weekend saw wall-to-wall coverage of T in the Park on the BBC. If they can cover that why not do the same with the Edinburgh festivals?

I prefer any of these options to the last possible reason why coverage of Scotland by the BBC is so Lilliputian, that reason being a cynical political instrument to reduce national identity and its political correlation, nationalism. In which case, the last time I saw state-media bias like this I was standing in Red Square reading Pravda.

Scottish licence fee payers should get a discount on account of the lack of accuracy, relevancy and the attempts to subvert the will of the people. As it stands, we're being short-changed.

Share this story on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: Wardog, Buckie on 9:16pm Sat 19 Jul 08


Well well well
Posted by: Grobert, Inverclyde on 9:24pm Sat 19 Jul 08
well, well, well said. Why is Scotland not in the main news?
Posted by: Wilhelm on 9:37pm Sat 19 Jul 08
Scotland pays 10 % of the BBC budget
And all they have made in Scotland in the last 50 years is Balamory.

Meanwhile on Osama Bin Laden's favourite tv station, Channel 4.
Monday night, a 2 hour programme about the Koran. Yeah, riveting stuff.
Monday night. a 1 hour programme called Sharia Law, a magazine, chat show for muslims. Whats the latest burqua styles that a muslim woman can be seen in down town Damascus and how to make a home grown bomb just using a fairy liqiud bottle and some scotch tape.

There aint any Christan or Jewish programmes on TV but there's a hell of a lot of muslim programmes on tv.
Posted by: Tam Glen, the but n ben on 10:06pm Sat 19 Jul 08
Its not just the weather maps that are skewed.

No its not, but the Government could order the BBC to change the lop-sided map they use.
Posted by: JWil on 10:34pm Sat 19 Jul 08
What annoys me most is that the BBC send teams from the south to make programmes about Scotland. The latest was St Kilda. They hardly mentioned this was Scotland, there was hardly a Scottish voice and from what the three southerners that were landed on the Islands were saying you could have thought that they had discovered the place and all its history.

Scotland has historians, archaeolgists and wildlife experts, so why does the BBC have to import them from the South.

There have been many productions of the same ilk where they are all run from London and very few Scots are involved in the projects. Its tantamount to robbery of Scottish assets and potential income.

So not only do the BBC withold a fair share of the funding from Scotland they basically take over its scenery, its wildlife, its heritage and a proportion of its economy.

The sooner ownership of Scottish broadcasting is taken from the BBC and put into Scottish hands the better.
Posted by: Ronald, Glasgow on 11:55pm Sat 19 Jul 08
The most important function that the bbc perform is that of its news gathering/current affairs department.
Sadly, it is now what it always was ; a creature of the right. A fawning, simpering sniveling entity which, rather than standing up to and challenging the most evil Junta this Country has ever experienced, has rolled over
and played brain-dead.
An utterly shamefull orginisation run by a
veritable legion of liars.
Posted by: pints, capital on 12:32am Sun 20 Jul 08
How much more bias from the BBC will we take before someone organises a boycott of the licence fee here in Scotland.
Throughout the troubles in Northern Ireland, a large proportion of the populous refused to pay their licence fee and the BBC, with silent support from the British Government, did nothing.
This boycott, arranged by the republican movement, went unreported in the British media.
The outcome was a more balanced reporting of news and current affairs programmes broadcast in Ulster.
Posted by: pints, capital on 12:33am Sun 20 Jul 08
How much more bias from the BBC will we take before someone organises a boycott of the licence fee here in Scotland.
Throughout the troubles in Northern Ireland, a large proportion of the populous refused to pay their licence fee and the BBC, with silent support from the British Government, did nothing.
This boycott, arranged by the republican movement, went unreported in the British media.
The outcome was a more balanced reporting of news and current affairs programmes broadcast in Ulster.
Posted by: pints, capital on 12:38am Sun 20 Jul 08
How many just and true would be needed to stand forward and follow through with a BBC licence fee boycott?
10, 100, 200, or even 1000.
If the greater proportion of the populous receives their news from the TV then I postulate the same number of boycotters as the 1000 SNP activists working in Glasgow East this weekend would advance a fairer un-bias broadcasting corporation. A greater understanding amongst the electorate of not just Glasgow East but the whole of Scotland, nay the British Isles, may result.
Posted by: tally, England on 12:58am Sun 20 Jul 08
The bbc is only following the governments agenda that nothing has changed since devolution. all political parties are guilty of clouding the issue of who they are talking about. The lib/dems for instance have a disclaimer making clear on their press releases that they talk of England or England and Wales. They then go on to talk about britain, the uk, or this country. No wonder the beeb is confused and transmit to Scotland.
I'm sure bbc reports to Scotland from England never actualluy mention the word "England"
Mant people in England have been demanding for years that the beeb stop using the word britain for England to no avail. Perhaps the new tartan enforcer can do something about it. They certainly don't listen to us.
Posted by: Faux Cu, Palais Bourbon on 8:22am Sun 20 Jul 08
Kate

I can see individual streets in St Malo on the BBC weather map. France is bigger than Scotland
Posted by: mchardie on 8:31am Sun 20 Jul 08
A license strike sounds like a good idea,but the timing is crucial.
Posted by: T Ritchie, Derbyshire England on 10:35am Sun 20 Jul 08
The only fair way to resolve the national coverage issue is for the nations of the UK to each have their own broadcaster financed one way or another by their own viewers.

Personally I would prefer the abolition of the viewing tax which guarantees the BBC's income whether viewers agree with its agenda or not, or whether or not they ever watch BBC channels.

However, if there were national broadcasters, the funding arrangements in Scotland should only be a matter for the Scots.

T Ritchie, Derbyshire, England.
Posted by: Peter, Aberdeenshire on 12:38pm Sun 20 Jul 08
I have complained to the BBC about bias before and have written to the licence authority to question why i should pay a licence to what is basically the broadcast arm of the Labour party, especially here in Scotland. It would seem that going by the number of times this issue is raised many people feel the same.
Posted by: Buckpool Loon, Cheshire on 1:08pm Sun 20 Jul 08
Even down here it's patently obvious the BBC News and current affairs programmes are spun to the edge of propaganda.

The BBC is purely a instrument of the State; a boring relic that has lost all claim to incisive or impartial reporting. Its news, views and programming dooms its viewers to a state of comatose incredulity.

But, perhaps that is exactly what its political master want? Entertainment designed by: Dumb, Doolally and Doolitle.
Posted by: Buckpool Loon, Cheshire on 1:14pm Sun 20 Jul 08
And I meant to add.

No matter how skewed the weather map is at least the weatherman is forced to acknowledge Scotland exists. That's not the case for the news or current affairs.

Seems the only answer is independence to all these inequalities, real or imagined or simply not comprehended by those who practice them.
Posted by: Ronald, Glasgow on 1:36pm Sun 20 Jul 08
Er.... "how long before someone orginises
a boycott of the bbc, and witholds the licence fee ? " Duhh ....... JUST FECKIN DO IT !!!
I have witheld my nazi-tax for over two years,
and these right wing scumbags will be singing Dixie before I ever subsidise their filthy
lie-machine !!
Posted by: JohnM, Perth on 9:49pm Sun 20 Jul 08
Ronald - nothing like direct action! Brave man! Have you not seen the Stasi ads about "we know where you live sucker, you're on our database"?

We know where our place is in Scotland - that's somewhere on the top rhs of the screen, just about recognisable on the weather map, as the main topic of the day weather wise being trotted out is what it's to be doing in London/any major sporting event in the South of England. I've forgotten now what the half-a$$ed explanation was for that crazy map but I do feel in Scotland anywhere north of Englandshire that we're all being skewed.
Posted by: JC on 12:41am Mon 21 Jul 08
Och.... It's all those nasty English again! yawn....
I like unbiased news about Scotland, which is why I don't buy the Sunday Herald anymore
Posted by: Ian, Argyll on 7:58am Tue 22 Jul 08
#JC
But you still read the Sunday Herald don't you JC? I know you do because you are reading and posting on the Sunday Herald website. D'uh!

This is all right enough. The main news has nothing of Scotland in it. Night after night.
The question is what we do about it?
Add your comment
Name:
Email: *
Location:
**
Security Image. Registered site users are not required to enter Security Image Information.
 
 e.g. 123-123
Comment:
Please note: All HTML tags will be ignored.
Format Text:

 
By posting a comment, I confirm that I have read and agree to the terms of use. Comments are not moderated but we will react if anything that breaks the rules comes to our attention and we may delete inappropriate postings. Please treat other people with respect. You must not post anything that is abusive, indecent, unlawful or defamatory. Remember, you are personally liable for what you post on this site. If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us here.
* Your email address will not be displayed
** To avoid register now or login